Dime Dropper
All-Star
I think the Jason Kidd comparison is good, because of his size, lack of shooting, etc. I could kind of see him in that role, but the NBA has changed a whole lot since Kidd was in his heyday -- PGs are way faster, and I'm not quite as sure someone who lacks serious speed can be as effective. Bibby isn't the same type of player as these guys, but look how his game has fallen off the planet because he can't penetrate anymore.
I certainly think it's impressive that Rubio is doing so well against real competition at that age, but I don't think it's unprecedented. Maravich scored 44 ppg as a college freshman, LeBron was hardly past 18 when he came into the NBA, etc. etc. Rubio's good, but not dominant, and while he's got a bright future I'm just not sold yet.
Just to be clear - I'm not saying Rubio will be a superstar. He is never going to lead a team to a title by himself ala LeBron, Kobe etc. However, he is going to be a great PG in the League for a long time. Great meaning he will certainly be capable of being the PG of a championship team. Apart from this he's the perfect PG for a rebuilding team. Not only is he young, but he's smart like a vet and is pass-first. And his passing and vision are off the charts.
I just think he's going to be a very, very exciting young PG when he endters the League. Never going to be your dominant player, but a fine PG who amazes you with something new each game.
I think some people are confused over what they think they should be getting. Some think to be picked top 5 you need to have that superstar potential. Rubio doesn't have that. He's simply not the physical specimen that guys like Jennings, Holiday etc. are. But with Rubios talents, I'd be putting my money on Rubio to have a more successful NBA career than Jennings (successful meaning more 'chips, better overall PG etc.).