Milk -- Really, really good. The performances were amazing across the board. Including Sean Penn, whom I usually find overrated. The way Gus Van Sant mixed new and archival footage was also quite impressive. I have, unfortunately, seen very few of the big Oscar nominees this year, but this one is at the top of my list so far.
Hancock -- Watching this film, it felt like it didn't know what kind of movie it wanted to be. Watching some of the DVD bonus features, they mentioned that the original script, which was quite dark, was tweaked a bit to make the film more accessible, and I think that's where the problem was. Ultimately, while I think the film was heavily flawed, I enjoyed it more than I thought it would. Too bad with the tweaking, though; I think it could have been much better if they'd either stayed completely dark or gone completely silly.