Tropical Island Video Vault Draft - ROUND 20 - FINAL ROUND

I was torn on that pick. Now I'm sure I made the right choice.

Nothing like some praise (or abuse) to re-assure yourself that you made the right choice. You hurt me with that one, man.


Uolj, there are a lot of films I'd like to take with my next pick, unfortunately most of them will fall to you so I wouldn't worry, even if we do have similar tastes in movies.
 

Warhawk

Give blood and save a life!
Staff member
Watchmen, Gladiator, Usual Suspects - all on my list. Some good choices there. Unfortunately, for the rest of us.
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
All good picks, all movies I like and own, all movies I'd gladly watch when a friend comes over and I say "Hey, let's watch a movie"... not movies I watch on my own, thus I was never a threat to pick any of them.
 

Capt. Factorial

ceterum censeo delendum esse Argentum
Staff member
Rather than have the rule about ratings it seems like it'd be easier to just make a rule that anyone who tries to sneak any porn in gets disqualified.
Sometimes it's nice to have an objective measure. You'd hate to have to have an argument over whether or not something borderline was porn, under the threat of disqualification. Ratings actually seems easier.
 

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
I guess I am naive because I am having a hard time trying to understand why anyone would even bother trying to sneak porn on in the first place. (I mean if this were a real island, yeah, then I'd get it).
 
I guess I am naive because I am having a hard time trying to understand why anyone would even bother trying to sneak porn on in the first place.
Yeah I don't see it either. It would take a real putz to try and cheat the rules on an internet game to sneak some porn onto their imaginary island. I don't think anyone here is that big of a loser, lol.
 
I could have gone a different direction with this, but this is one of my favourite movies ever, and I want it on my island. It's not all light and fluffy, but it has harrowing dialogue and a fantastic performance from it's lead actor.



American History X (1998)

This is Ed Norton's best performance IMO. It's a very interesting film which opens up a world or hatred, bias, and a range of other issues.
 
I could have gone a different direction with this, but this is one of my favourite movies ever, and I want it on my island. It's not all light and fluffy, but it has harrowing dialogue and a fantastic performance from it's lead actor.



American History X (1998)

This is Ed Norton's best performance IMO. It's a very interesting film which opens up a world or hatred, bias, and a range of other issues.
Nice pick. That is a favorite of mine for Norton's performance alone. i don't know if i'd call it a great film overall but it's a very good one with quote a few great and memorable scenes like the dinner table, the grocery store, and some of the prison stuff.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
I would classify American History X as a movie of interest for me that I paused over, but not as one I would want to be stuck watching for eternity. I think I've seen it twice, think its a great film with a great lead performance. But not sure I will ever watch it again on my own. Maybe to show it to somebody. Otherwise can't imagine what mood I would have to be in to say "hey, time to take a load off...hmmm...I'm in the mood for some foul mouthed psychotic neo-nazis! Woot!"
 
I would classify American History X as a movie of interest for me that I paused over, but not as one I would want to be stuck watching for eternity. I think I've seen it twice, think its a great film with a great lead performance. But not sure I will ever watch it again on my own. Maybe to show it to somebody. Otherwise can't imagine what mood I would have to be in to say "hey, time to take a load off...hmmm...I'm in the mood for some foul mouthed psychotic neo-nazis! Woot!"
It's one I wouldn't pick only because I watched it so much in the late 90s and early 2000s that i burned myself out on it and it just doesn't seem to have the timeless quality that great films need.
 
I would classify American History X as a movie of interest for me that I paused over, but not as one I would want to be stuck watching for eternity. I think I've seen it twice, think its a great film with a great lead performance. But not sure I will ever watch it again on my own. Maybe to show it to somebody. Otherwise can't imagine what mood I would have to be in to say "hey, time to take a load off...hmmm...I'm in the mood for some foul mouthed psychotic neo-nazis! Woot!"

The idea of an island never really comes into it for me. I think it's more of a way to justify this whole process. I just pick the best movies - I think the best movies are always re-watchable. Of course, the best movies is a subjective thing. Nonetheless, I've seen American History X multiple times, and it's yet to get old for me.

I took a risk with that pick, there's a couple others I'd comfortably take over it in terms of enjoyment, but I think this had less chance of making it to my next pick. Oh well. Have to wait and see what happens.
 
American Beauty and American History X were both favorites of my high school and college years. I'm not convinced of their infinite rewatchability, but they are each quality pictures :).
 
American Beauty and American History X were both favorites of my high school and college years. I'm not convinced of their infinite rewatchability, but they are each quality pictures :).
I've found American Beauty to be very rewatcable. it's one of those films that's gone higher and higher on my favorites list as years go by. I love the tone of it, the characters, the dialog, the performances, the overall message, etc. It's a rare film where they got everything just right.
 
I'm agonizing over this one also. Rather than say too much, I'll just make my pick. Despite a major (MAJOR) plothole, this movie has great storytelling and is incredibly rewatchable.

With the 35th pick in the 2011 TDOS Tropical Island Video Vault Draft, Superman's Super Movie Lineup selects:
The Prestige (2006), directed by Christopher Nolan

No one cares about the man in the box.

I've only seen The Prestige once but loved it. Nolan's best film for me and I've seen all of his films.
 
The Prestige is a very good film. Would have picked it in a few rounds but was never much chance of it falling. BTW, watched Inception again the other day, much better on second viewing. I'm liking your list so far, Superman.
 
So far, even though there's been nothing taken so far that I would have had on my list (except probably Inglorious Basterds, or Grindhouse if it was still hanging out in the late rounds), this bunch scares me way more than the group picking movies last time. Don't know why. It's going to be a loooooooooong eleven picks for me.

Hoping at this point the same forgetfulness present in the last draft carries over to this one.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
So far, even though there's been nothing taken so far that I would have had on my list (except probably Inglorious Basterds, or Grindhouse if it was still hanging out in the late rounds), this bunch scares me way more than the group picking movies last time. Don't know why. It's going to be a loooooooooong eleven picks for me.

Hoping at this point the same forgetfulness present in the last draft carries over to this one.
Its because its a bunch of Nolan loving hipster envying pretentious wannabe film majors...just like yourself! :p
 
I've been going back and forth with this choice. I'll go with the blockbuster as it probably will not get back to me. Sure, it may not hold up to 2,075 re-viewings, but the cinematography alone make it a special film, and the story has some basic elements of emotional connection that there's enough substance there to return to. This film was powerful enough to make me retroactively vote for Bozzwell's film in the Make-Your-Own-Movie Draft even without a write-up, given Cameron's power to amaze in the sci-fi genre. With my 3rd pick I select:

Avatar (2009)






Now I'll have plenty of time to explore Pandora!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I’m going with a film I’m really surprised is still here, Goodfellas. I’m pretty sure I’ll be able to grab plenty of my more obscure favorites in the later rounds so I don’t want to let this one get away.

Few films put you into the inner world of the characters like this one does. Watching it almost makes you feel like you’re part of their crew. It’s great story telling that’s very funny at times, disturbingly violent at others, and overall is just darn entertaining.

 
Flying home tomorrow, by the way. Suspect it won't take up enough of my day that I hold up the draft for hours and hours (if the snake even gets back to me when I'm traveling, that is), but if no one hears from me until mid-evening California time, that's why. Will make sure to check in when I get settled to make extra sure I don't time out.



Also, don't nobody better steal my next movie.