Think the best defense for Geoff on this is just that at this late date there are few if any other players of Mo's overall caliber left to sign on the frontcourt -- so not much else to choose from. I don't think Geoff has been anything more than average for some time now, but what little he has done has been almost exclusively opportunistic the last few years. Reef -- only when the Jersey deal broke down. Salmons -- when God told him not to go to Toronto. Keon suddenly hit the market late. JJ was sitting at home when the season started. Ron (if that was even Geoff) when Ron went nutso and suddenly hit the market, etc. Master of swooping in suddenly when a deal goes bad. So Mo would fit right in as a guy who pops up on the market out of the blue after being bought out.
On the flipside, it could just be one more nail in the Petrie coffin as a guy who values offensive ability first, second, and third, and so accumlates soft, small frontcourt players like they are candy.
Partly true. However, being able to jump at the sign of opportunity is also a huge skill. Say whatever about Reef's softness (though playing with jaw shut does not shout soft to me), but he is a bargain at MLE.
As to Petrie valuing offensive skill over toughness, it might also be partly due to Adleman. When we had the occasional tough guy (Pollard, Tag, Potato), he didn't use them much. In fact, Miller had a bit of a reputation as a bad boy, and now he has morphed into a softie
. At the same time, Rick also deserves credit for getting career performances from his players, and resurrecting the career of JJ.
Petrie's recent record with trades is not glittering, but it is partly due to our reluctance to sign or S&T our own free agents. Doug's trade for Mobley, Bobby and Tag for Bonzi were not bad trades, and Darius for two second rounders, I thought was brilliant. However, since we let these guys walk, they seem bad.
Finally, there is so much more to a GM than trades. For several years, we traded away our future in the form of draft picks in an effort to win now. Talented young guys on our roster weren't given a chance due to talent overload. Since then, he has changed a highly paid veteran, but ageing roster, to a relatively younger roster below the luxury cap, while managing to reach the playoffs each time in a tough West. (low by our recent lofty standards, but a huge achievement none the less). With low draft picks, he has managed to pick guys that have fans excited and hopeful. While time shall tell if the kids justify this hope, Petrie's record in plucking good players with low draft picks is excellent.