I'm kind of all over the place myself. I'd probably go Mathurin, Murray, Davis and then Griffin. Mathurin seems like the safest bet but he may have a lower ceiling than Murray/Davis. The Kings really need their next player to hit a high ceiling and not just merely be a roleplayer.
I really like Keegan Murray's game but I was reading on realgm and someone posted this...
I would be very hesitant to take someone his age in the top 5. He'll be almost 22 on draft night, and this is the list from the last 20 years of guys who were over 21 yrs old and drafted in the top 5
kris dunn
thomas robinson
wesley johnson
evan turner
hasheem thabeet
al horford
adam morrison
shelden wiliams
raymond felton
emeka okafor
ben gordon
devin harris
dwyane wade
mike dunleavy
That's not the best list there but who knows if the list of players with that criteria taken 6-10 is completely different. Age does have a big factor though so we can't discount that. He's only in his second year but he'll basically be a senior's age when he's drafted.
Who do you have?
I have
5.Davis
6.Murray
7.Griffin
8.Mathurin
I'm just getting super bullish on Davis's overall 2-way game. He's so advanced on the offensive end as a scorer with what I could only describe as "NBA Star" type of scoring moves. The term "3-level scorer" got thrown around so much last year towards Green and Bouknight especially, but I think it actually applies to what Davis has been doing this year. We haven't gotten to see a real off-ball game from him, but Wisconsin obviously needs him to handle the massive USG rate for them to win. I think his 3pt shooting could really sky-rocket when he's not the sole focus of defensive attention and gets some shots created for him. I'd be pretty excited how he could apply his offensive IQ to an off-ball role playing off Sabonis.
Defensively, he just works his ass off and is quite effective as an on and off ball defender. Moves extremely well laterally and is constantly fighting through screens to stay in front. I think that really speaks to his drive/motor, because a lot of the time, most of the top NCAA offensive players will coast on D to save their energy. That's what surprised me most when I started to watch; he's actually a really effective and willing defender.
Maybe a hot-take, but I've seen a lot more out of Davis than Green or Bouknight last year in terms of being a far more complete player with the defense/rebounding and being the better "3-level scorer" label then either guy. We've seen Green and Bouknight struggle with NBA physicality that Davis shouldn't have the same problem with. He's pretty clearly a 2, but he's a well-built 2 at 6'5 with what should be a positive wingspan by looking at him (can't find it anywhere online).
After those 4 there's a pretty large tier break too (in some order, haven't really nailed anything down yet)
Eason
Brown
Duren
Sochan
Ochai Agbaji
EJ Liddell (hot take alert?)
Kessler
Williams
Moore
I think Liddell is the Desmond Bane/Brandon Clarke/Herb Jones of this draft. He's gotten significantly better every season, he has an excellent 4 frame for the NBA (6'7/240/7'0 wingspan), he's developed as a dynamic rim protector and defender this year especially that works ridiculously hard on D. He's a good athlete that shouldn't have any problems stepping out on 4's and defending the perimeter. The offensive stats are silly good (30% USG, 59% TS, .490 FTr) and has gotten his 3pt shooting to a real appealing 37.5% on 3.7 attempts/game. There's growth potential too if he can keep developing his perimeter on-ball game that's shown flashes this season. I've seen some comps to Grant Williams, which seems pretty solid, but I like Liddell rim protection more and I like his offensive game to translate (especially if he can bring his shot) to the next level.
Eventually, teams will learn to ignore age with some of these prospects if the skill-set/talent is transferable to the NBA. It's one of the biggest edges left in talent evaluation imo.