I did not want this trade to happen. It appears that I am in the minority with that opinion, but I am still glad that it seems dead. I am NOT against trading any player, but I just did not see AI being happy here. Nor did I believe that the others players on our team would benefit from it.
The general mood does seem to be of depression, but I too didn't think getting Iverson was a very good idea. His history is too sketchy, and we already have one such guy in the locker room. Iverson has feuded with all his coaches, and Muss would be a light weight for him (add Artest to the mix, and Muss just might throw up his hands and quit too).
Is he better than Bibby? Sure. If we could also offload KT, does that help. Sure it does. Despite this, following needs to be remembered
1. Apart from the year when they went to the finals (I know that's a big apart), Iverson hasn't won much. Recently, Philly has missed the playoffs, and with or without Iverson, would have missed it this year too (even in the East).
2. He has not existed with other stars (nor has Artest). This would have gotten ugly soon.
3. Young guys have rarely propered in his shadow. Don't know if they were not good enough to begin with, or the culture of the organization is more to blame than AI. That's a big question though, with us grooming some young guys to play bigger roles in future.
4. Doesn't help our cap. Per hoopshype, Bibby and KT shall make a combined 21M next year, while AI shall make about 20. Plus, we shall need to sign another "big" guy to shore up our already woefully thin front court. On other other hand, if Bibby opts out next year (will the current events prompt him to?), we might have some good cap for a major signing (we shall need a PG of course).
5. We shall remain mediocre. West is too tough. With Iverson, or with Bibby and KT, we might make the playoffs as 7-8th seed, or miss it. We are not going to be contenders either way.
The best option might be to trade Bibby and or some other guys (Reef has a smallish contract and is a good low post scorer, something a lot of teams could use; Chicago for example) for future picks. This shall allow us to stink bad this year, and hopefully land a high pick, while at the same time, clearing up space for a major signing. Easier said than done though.