If it were as simple as you stated, I would agree. I think they are MUCH closer as prospects than you however.
Aldrich isn't a lumbering center, he is quite mobile himself. He is not quite as explosive a leaper, but is still pretty agile. Udoh is indeed a very good shot blocker, but don't forget that it was Aldrich that averaged more blocks on the year while also hauling in significantly more rebounds.
To my eye Aldrich was also the superior man defender between the two because he has a stronger base that makes him more difficult to back down in the post, something that is important and needed on this team. I am not saying Udoh was bad mind you, but he is going to have to add a good bit of strength to his lower body because I saw him get overpowered much more than Aldrich.
On offense obviously Udoh has the superior potential, I don't think anyone would really argue that. However one thing that gets overlooked about Aldrich on offense is that he sets fantastic screens and can work the pick and roll (as well as defend it). Overall Aldrich did take a half-step back on offense this season, but looking at the guys surrounding him I think a big part of it was that they didn't do as good a job getting him involved in the offense.
I see more of what I want to see on the Kings team in Aldrich than I do in Udoh, with the fact that he is younger being a nice little plus. I can respect those that see otherwise, but I think a lot of people sell Aldrich short because he isn't a guy that wows fans as much.
Aldrich isn't a lumbering center, he is quite mobile himself. He is not quite as explosive a leaper, but is still pretty agile. Udoh is indeed a very good shot blocker, but don't forget that it was Aldrich that averaged more blocks on the year while also hauling in significantly more rebounds.
To my eye Aldrich was also the superior man defender between the two because he has a stronger base that makes him more difficult to back down in the post, something that is important and needed on this team. I am not saying Udoh was bad mind you, but he is going to have to add a good bit of strength to his lower body because I saw him get overpowered much more than Aldrich.
On offense obviously Udoh has the superior potential, I don't think anyone would really argue that. However one thing that gets overlooked about Aldrich on offense is that he sets fantastic screens and can work the pick and roll (as well as defend it). Overall Aldrich did take a half-step back on offense this season, but looking at the guys surrounding him I think a big part of it was that they didn't do as good a job getting him involved in the offense.
I see more of what I want to see on the Kings team in Aldrich than I do in Udoh, with the fact that he is younger being a nice little plus. I can respect those that see otherwise, but I think a lot of people sell Aldrich short because he isn't a guy that wows fans as much.
First off lets set the record straight. Aldrich averaged 3.5 blocks per game, which is a nice average. Udoh averaged 3.7 blocks a game. Aldrich averaged 9.8 rebounds a game and Udoh averaged 9.8 rebounds a game. Aldrich aveaged 11.3 points per game and Udoh averaged 13.9 points per game. And please don't come back with per 40 stats. I think thats the most worthless stat in college basketball where there are so many variables it makes your head spin. Just ask Derrick Favors.
So to my mind, if your determined to pick a center, then Aldrich is the best one available right now after Cousins. Now its possible that Alabi or Whiteside etc. may be better in the future, but if your looking for someone thats able to step in and play right now, Aldrich is your choice. And I feel confident he'll certainly help on the defensive side.
But if the team decides that JT's best position is Center, and I don't think there's any doubt that he's played better at that position since he's filled in for Hawes. Well then maybe you look for a PF thats a defensive player. And to my mind, Udoh is the next best defensive PF after Favors. His age doesn't bother me that much. Ask yourself how long any player usually stays with any one team on average. 5 or 6 years maybe? The exceptions are the Kobe's and Wade's of the world. But even if Udoh were to be with the team ten years, he still would only be 33 years old. To say that a 22 year old player has no upside because of his age would be saying that Karl Malone, John Stockton, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Hakeem Olajuwon etc. had no upside because they were 21 or 22 years old. Wilt Chamberlin was 23 years old when he came into the league.
Now if you set position aside, and want the best future all around player of the two. Then it would only take one game of watching both players for you to quickly decide that Udoh has the biggest upside on offense. Watching Aldrich shoot his jumper, or his foul shots is almost painful. Noah's freethrow shot looks like a thing of beauty by comparison. Unless Aldrich completely revamps his shot, I can't see him ever being a force on offense. He is what he is. A very good defensive center who can get you 10 or 12 points a game by accident. His post game is better, but there absolutely no fluidity to it. Sometimes he looks as though he just throwing the ball in the direction of the basket.
Udoh is the exact opposite of Aldrich. You watch him play and you know that with more practice and work, he could become a good offensive player. He's a better ballhandler and passer than Aldrich. And while I think Aldrich is a pretty good athlete for a big man, I don't think there's even a contest over whose the better athlete.
So once again. Its just a matter of picking your poison. Do we want a center, or do we want a PF. Not being able to read Petrie's mind, I have no idea which way he would go if it comes down to Aldrich or Udoh.
By the way, I like Wesley Johnson a lot. And yes he could play some SG. But bear in mind that he's not Evan Turner. He doesn't have Turners ballhandling or passing skills, and I think thats a prerequisite for whomever they put at that position for the future. But Johnson would be a hell of a SF. The problem is, what do you do with Greene, Nocioni, and Casspi. Doesn't make any sense to me. Maybe you trade down a couple of spots is someone makes you a good offer..