SLAB
Hall of Famer
More athletic/more coordinated =/= better offensively. To whatever extent it might be true, it's a specious argument at best, and really, we're talking about two career bench weights... Justin Williams is "better offensively" than Shelden Williams in about the same respect that Desagana Diop is "better offensively" than Adonal Foyle. I suppose I'd rather lob the ball to Diop than Foyle, but if I have a guy who, under a DEFCOM 3 situation might actually get minutes, I'd take Foyle. And that's how I feel about Shelden Williams. His career stats bear out that, when he gets 10+ minutes, he actually is not completely worthless. I'd bet you anything that, if he were getting Moore's minutes (17 per versus 9), he'd be putting up better numbers. I'm not willing to go out on a limb and say that about Justin.
I remember Justin having a few starts back when, and when he got his minutes looked decent enough. Even logging a few double-doubles.
That said however, yes they are both career bench weights, and I reiterate that the fact a game thread turning into a Sheldon V. Justin debate is just sad sad sad...