Is Herb Jones a SG? I watched him for years in college he never struck me as a player thats more of a guard than a forward.
He is more of a forward to me too, but I feel he is capable of playing as a defensive 3&D SG in this hypothetical lineup because of Murray's and Cam's shooting and off-ball movement. Besides, Mike Brown can opt to play Huerter/Monk at SG and Herb at SF for a lot of minutes too, when a third play-maker is needed. So he has warts on offense but for a defensive 3&D SG who plays within his strengths, it should be just fine IMO. He focuses on fast-breaks, takes most of his threes from the corner/wing, with occasional cuts and straight drives and to the rim.
One positive for Herb over Vando, is that Herb is a better 3-point shooter.
3PA per 36: Herb - 3.1, Vando - 1.7
3P% per 36: Herb - 34%, Vando - 32%
Corner 3 attempted: Herb - 52%, Vando 88%
The difference in corner 3's attempted shows that Herb is more comfortable taking threes from the wing. This is important for 2 reasons:
1) If Murray/Cam are also taking lots of corner threes, it would be helpful for the player next to them to be comfortable or decent at shooting threes from the wing.
2) Vando positions himself in the corner more, on offense. On the occasions when Herb is located on the wing, if a shot is missed, then it would be easier for Herb to get back on defense from where he is located to try and stop the break.
Also, there's no chance of getting Vando this summer... while there is a slim possibility of getting Herb, since the Pels need more shooting around BI, Zion and Jonas when Zion is back... so there is no point in thinking about Vando.
I think thats a totally ridiculous question about which groups rebounding is better...
Why is it so ridiculous? Herb is 6'8", Cam is 6'8"-6'9". Huerter is 6'7" but soft on rebounding, Monk is 6'3" and a non-factor on rebounding, Vando is 6'9". Of course, Herb and Cam are going to rebound better than a combo of Huerter/Monk and Vando.
Do you think Herb Jones at SG saves us from that 3rd quarter game7 slaughter on the boards? Is that what your saying? Cuz I think your underrating the quality of our potential playoff opponents to try and make your point. Herb Jones is gonna guard Klay Thompson at the 3pt line and simultaneously save our rebounding? That seems plausible to you?
That's a ridiculous counter question to ask, for a couple of reasons.
1) You are making this all about rebounding, while ignoring the other improvements (such as improved three-point shooting and defense). I'm not under-rating opponents... and I'm not saying my hypothetical lineup has an answer for everything. I simply think it has more answers than the current roster, or other lineups that I'm seeing posted here.
Is it possible you are unable to see the bigger picture, when the pieces of the jigsaw have not already been put together? Rosters are all about options. It would be nice for the Kings to get another backup PF who is 6'10" or more and can play alongside Sabonis. Someone like Maxi Kleber, or Taylor Hendricks (altho he is not gettable in this draft). It's not like Herb will or should play all 48 minutes. The Kings also need a better backup Center.
2) The question you are asking about "guarding the 3pt line while simultaneously saving our rebounding", well, that would apply equally to Vanderbilt. In a hypothetical lineup of Fox - Monk/Huerter - Murray - Vando - Saboni, if Klay was going off, then the smart move would be to have Vando guarding Klay. So is Vando going to guard Klay on the perimeter and simultaneously save the rebounding? No, he is not.
With Sabonis at C, the team is always going to have problems rebounding. The hope is that having three guys who are 6'8" (Herb. Murray, Cam) playing between Fox-Sabonis will help reduce the problem. Two of these three 6'8" guys are superb three-point shooters, while the other is good enough. One of the three is a superb defender, while the other two are good enough. They may not grab many more rebounds at the rim, but they can help grab those that are further from the basket. The rebounding is a Sabonis-problem which won't be solved unless you get a bigger body next to him (like Claxton, who can also defend perimeter players). Simply dropping Vando into the lineup won't solve the problem,
depending on who Vando is guarding.