I think saying he was bad in DET is a bit disingenuous. He was essentially asked to be THE guy in DET surrounded by a bunch of inexperienced players. I would just say he was in the wrong role. He’s not a #1 scorer but he’s proven to be a very solid & efficient secondary option.
I guess we disagree that Grant is only a slightly better scorer than Barnes but let’s be clear. You’re not just paying for a better scorer. You’re paying for a better & more versatile defender, a better rim protector, a better shooter, a better matchup when opposing teams have a lot of length at PF, and a younger player.
The games played the last few seasons is concerning but I’m wondering how many of these missed games are due to tanking/shutting him down. After all, he has been on 3 bottom dwelling teams the past few seasons while he’s missed few games in the seasons prior. I’m sure some in depth research would confirm if that theory is true but I’m too lazy to look.
Defensively, he’s still a good defender today, and I have faith he’d flourish here defensively considering the reports of how coachable he is and the fact that we’d have Mike Brown in his ears. Also, I think come playoff time when defense is a little less about effort and more about defensive skill (since everyone is typically trying really hard on defense in the playoffs), I think Grant’s defense translates really well to the playoff game.
I guess the last thing I’ll say is that $100 mil/4 years is likely not going to land you some star talent who’s a tier above Grant. I think you’ll come up empty searching for a FA signing who will agree to that amount of money while also giving you absolute confidence that he’d step in right away and help get this team into a WCF. Hell I could easily see Cam Johnson costing that much this off-season. Does he constitute a player that will catapult this team into the WCF? I don’t think so. The first year salary of max contracts this year are going to be $33.5 mil/$40.2 mil/$46.9 mil. Next year, it will be $35.75 mil/$42.9 mil/$50.05 mil. And if the salary cap takes a big jump to $171 mil for the 2025-26 season (due to the new TV deal), you’re looking at $42.75 mil/$51.3 mil/$59.85 mil. I don’t think signing a guy like Grant to $25-30 mil is going to hamstring as much as people think. Players are going to be getting some ridiculous contracts here pretty soon.