Actually, you're wrong again. The other thread is an open letter of gratitude to Doug.
This thread is the "official" thread about everything related to the trade. People are posting their impressions. Some of them may talk more about Doug's defensive presence; others may discuss what they think the long-range benefits of the trade are. Some may even change their minds as more time goes by and the reality of the situation sinks in.
All you've done so far is make comments like "they are underselling Doug's defense."
Well, how? Where? Who? All I'm really saying is that instead of vague blanket criticisms of some of the posts here, quote one - just like you did mine - and let's discuss it instead of just generalizing about "a lot of people severely underplaying Doug's defense".