I pretty much agree with your points Superman. Basically I was saying that Peja is a shooter, always has been and always will be. Most of the comments about Peja not being able to create his own shot or not being tough enough would apply to any shooting specialist. He's not expected to be a do-everything player, he has a role to fill and when you talk about three point shooters, he's counted as one of the best. We don't critisize Shaq because he can't take the ball up the floor or shoot an open 20-footer. Yeah it'd be great if he could do those things, but they aren't part of his job on the basketball floor so it's just understood that he's a center. That's his role. And it should be the same with a shooting specialist.
The flip side of that is that it's prefectly reasonable to question whether a shooting specialist deserves a max contract given that in NBA competition, a talented big man is going to do a lot more for you than a guy who hangs out around the perimeter and knocks down threes. That's not true of every basketball competition, but it's true of the NBA. If you can only afford one or two max players, you'd be better off making them of the dominant big man type. I agree that breaking the bank for a shooter isn't a wise business move. I've never had any problem with that argument. I just thought some of these comments about Peja weren't acknowledging that, as a shooter, he has a specific role to play on the floor and that determines the way he plays the game. All shooters get less rebounds because they're always on the perimeter. All shooters need their teammates to set them up. You can argue against having that kind of player on your team of course, or at least having them be a primary option, but those aren't the arguments I've been hearing from some people. What I've been hearing is "Peja sucks at this" and "Peja can't do this."
If he can add those post moves he's talked about, then he becomes more of a multi-faceted threat. And at that point maybe you start thinking about a max contract, but that's in the speculative future right now. At this point in time, a max contract would be a poor decision I think.