I'm working off feelings here so bear with me... I am pretty sure New Orleans have had as many if not more All Star selections in ~20 years as we have had in 40 (probably wrong because Mitch was routinely an All Star but I think they must have chosen teams quite differently then as its hard to see Mitch being a fixture in the ASG in this era). But they have had 19 selections since they transferred the team formerly known as the Charlotte Hornets historical stats.Anthony Davis never winning a single MVP or DPOY award and not leading his team any further than the Conference Semi-Finals before teaming up with Lebron in LA has to count as a disappointment. Yeah some of that is that he was just on bad teams but he had Jrue Holiday, Tyreke Evans, and Eric Gordon as teammates early in his career. They should have been better than they were. He had his best chance after Vlade gave DeMarcus to the Pels but they ran into the KD version of the Warriors in the playoffs and Cousins got injured. It could be argued that circumstances breed superduperstars -- the right team, the right coach, the right timing. But then Giannis managed to win a championship with Jure Holiday as his best teammate along with 2 MVP awards and 1 DPOY award. Could also be that Anthony Davis wasn't good enough.
And yet they have historically been as bad if not worse than us. I think it must be coaching or just who they put on court besides the 1-2 all stars they seem to have selected routinely.
You can't convince me that AD wouldn't have turned a fringe playoff team into a serious contender over 2-3 seasons. He seems remarkably different than all the other players you mentioned. That's just me
