Desert Island Music Draft Thread *** draft is over ***

Deset Island Music Draft Finals *** Who Ya Got? ***

  • D-Mass

    Votes: 16 55.2%
  • bozzwell

    Votes: 13 44.8%

  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
tradepeja,

You better be surprised! I was gonna pick Nevermind as a strategic pick and take a chance that Pet Sounds would be available later, then at the last second I changed my mind and went with Pet Sounds.

BTW, classics are never cliche, and Nevermind was an instant classic.

Haha nice, good to know I'm not the only Nirvana fan.

Oh and the cliche part, I didn't mean the album was a cliche, i meant saying "i can't believe this is still available" is.
 
This is cliche'd by now, but seriously, I am very surprised this is still available. Maybe I'm the only grungehead here though....

nevermind.jpg


Nirvana - Nevermind (1991)

The best band of the 90's most memorable and influential album. The first six songs on this things are all probably in my top 50 songs ever. This iconic album includes Come As You Are, In Bloom, Breed, Polly, Lithium, and the pinnacle of the album and definitely a top 10 song ever, Smells Like Teen Spirit. All with their heavy and poetic lyrics, memorable riffs, they are all unforgettable songs that I can't go a couple weeks without hearing.

I want to say more about this album, but that's basically it. Excellent in every sense of the word.

Darn! I was hoping this would make it back to me for my second pick. I was surprised it lasted as long as it did, too.
 
It may not actually be my favorite album from my favorite band, but I've got to go with
The Clash - London Calling
TheClashLondonCallingalbumcover.jpg

Hailed by Rolling Stone as the greatest album of the 1980s it technically came out in 1979 but didn't arrive on our shores until the new year.

While I am more of a punk purist at heart, this gets the nod over their debut thanks to its musical diversity. Not to mention a double album is a good thing to have when you're marooned on a desert island and can only pick 20. This album really has all the bases covered - whether that be their punked up cover of the rockabilly Brand New Cadillac, upbeat ska/reggae such as Rudie Can't Fail and their reworking of Stagger Lee into Wrong 'em Boyo, the more dread-reggae stylings of Guns of Brixton to pure pop in the "hidden" Train in Vain. Other favorites include Death or Glory, Clampdown, Spanish Bombs and The Right Profile, a sad ode to the woes of Monty Clift.

Then there are two of my favorite songs, ever.

First up is Lost in the Supermarket, I'm pretty sure this would make my life stranded on the desert island seem wonderful compared to this poor sad sack. This song is one of the rare few that can be both depressing and uplifting all at once, depending on where you focus. And its always in the back of my mind whenever I enter a Costco or Target store.

Then there is The Card Cheat, the Clash did their own take on the Wall of Sound here recording everything twice. The grand piano opening and the tale of the card cheat who is discovered and shot on the spot stand out the most, but there's plenty more to this one - and on many occasions I have hit the repeat key to give it a second or third listen.

Not to mention this is probably my favorite album cover of all time - an homage to the King along with one of my favorite rock and roll photos ever. Not sure if they still have it, but in 2000 I got stuck in Cleveland for a few days and gazed in awe when I stumbled upon Paul Simonon's smashed up bass guitar.

I could rave on about this album and The Clash in general for hours but I think I will stop here before I do something dumb like accidentally press the refresh key and have to type this one up again.
 
Great pick pdxKingsFan. I was hoping it is not such an obvious pick and it would survive until later rounds. Guess I need to work on my strategy.
 
It may not actually be my favorite album from my favorite band, but I've got to go with
The Clash - London Calling


I'm glad you picked this one, as it justifies the decision to leave it off my list -- I knew someone would take it, eventually, and didn't want to become attached to too many and see them snatched away.

Absolutely agree on "Lost in the Supermarket." It's one of my very favorite Clash songs.
 
Great pick pdxKingsFan. I was hoping it is not such an obvious pick and it would survive until later rounds. Guess I need to work on my strategy.
If you saw my list it would've been obvious. I've only got 2 or 3 more that I expect competition over. After that I think I'll be delighted if anyone else nabs my not so obvious picks as I don't know many people that share the same tastes.
 
how odd... I always thought everyone had heard

Should I Stay or Should I Go and Rock the Casbah

guess it just goes to show that I take things for granted sometimes
 
how odd... I always thought everyone had heard

Should I Stay or Should I Go and Rock the Casbah

guess it just goes to show that I take things for granted sometimes

Maybe we just didn't know that was the Clash? :o My ignorance can know no bounds at times! :p
 
Of course neither of those songs are particularly indicative of the Clash's body of work. London Calling is a great starting off point - you can go backwards if you want rougher stuff and forwards if you want the more experimental (they released a triple album a mere 12 months after London Calling - 5 albums worth of material in such a short time is astonishing, especially by today's standards).
 
I actually was going to ask if there were any really iconic songs by them that most people have heard, but I knew it would come up eventually.

For the record, I have heard both of those.

Stop the catbox anyone?
 
Well, Nevermind was all queued up, only to be snatched a couple picks ahead of me. Early 1990's was when I first began to explore music. Nevermind was the first rock album I ever purchased myself. This album was the second.

Pearl Jam - Ten - 1991

9ee3eb6709a069efd1213110.L.jpg


This album is amazing. It expanded upon the blossoming success of the Seattle grunge scene. This has so many hits on it its ridiculous. Once, Even Flow, Black, and Jeremy are all some of my favorite songs of all time. My personal favorite song from Pearl Jam is Yellow Ledbetter, which came out of a recording session for Ten and appeared on the Jeremy single. I absolutely love this album.
 
Knew those two grunge pioneers were going to go sooner rather than later. Threw them in at the end of my list, but knew there was no way they would last until I would be picking them.
 
I have a list of forty and not one aside from Dark Side has been picked yet. I am quite certain I will get my next two and it seems I may go all the way uncontested. Until voting time that is.
 
Man, there's a lot of time until my next pick. I wonder if my #3 will hold.....

I wonder if GGG will pick any of the remaining (awesome) Beatles albums.
 
I've got a short list of 30 right now, with an even shorter list of 5 from which I hope to pick my next two from if they last through the next round and a half. I'm feeling pretty good about 10 of my picks making it the rest of the draft but am nervous and have been crunching the contingencies..."what could I' reaaaaaaaaaaallly live without having on an island if I'm stuck there forever..."

Prioritizing is becoming a virtue lol...
 
Dammit, I have my 3rd pick all locked up....now I'm getting nervous its gonna get stolen! Its freaking great


Man, I shoulda picked this one in round 1...........
 
Hmm...tsk, tsk, holding up the line here Prophetess!

Don't make me have to start posting random pics of fat hairy guys wearing tutus. :p
 
ya know, I do have to sleep sometimes. ;)

Simon and Garfunkel - Bridge Over Troubled Waters

This album brings back several different memories, and if I'm stuck on an island I want a variety of music that will evoke those memories and make me feel less lonely. Not to mention:

Bridge over Troubled Water is the fifth and final studio album by Simon and Garfunkel. [1] First released on January 26, 1970, it reached number one on Billboard Music Charts pop albums list. It won a Grammy Award for Album of the Year, as well as for Best Engineered Recording, while its title track won the Grammy Award for Record of the Year and Song of the Year in the Grammy Awards of 1971.[1] It has since sold over 25 million worldwide.
 

Attachments

  • 200px-BridgeWater.jpg
    200px-BridgeWater.jpg
    12.9 KB · Views: 77
And for me:

Dido - No Angel

I don't think I can descibe it better than allmusic.com does:

an auspicious and highly listenable album — atmospheric, seductive, and beautifully produced and sequenced.

This is a CD that I often put on in the car and an hour later wonder where the the past hour has gone. :D Again, one of the first albums I ever listened to that I can just play over and over and not get sick of any of it. I kick myself because when I first picked up the album I really didn't get around to listening to it for a few weeks. During that time she put on a concert in a small venue in a small town close to mine and I could have gone but didn't because I didn't "know" her music yet and didn't want to spend the meager funds I had at that time on something I wasn't sure I'd enjoy attending. After I listened to the album a couple times to get a good feel for it I was really bummed about my choice not to attend.

From wikipedia:

Her No Angel went on to become the top-selling album of 2001 in the United Kingdom, debuting at, and returning to, number one in the official UK albums chart many times throughout the year. It spawned two top ten hit singles, "Here with Me" and "Thank You", and a further top twenty hit, "Hunter" and a fourth and final single release "All You Want" which went top 25. It was certified platinum in over thirty-five countries, and is estimated to have sold over 15 million copies worldwide. It is the second biggest selling album of the 21st century in the UK.

Edit - PM sent.
 

Attachments

  • No Angel.jpg
    No Angel.jpg
    6.9 KB · Views: 77
Last edited:
i think this live recording (from one single concert) meets the rules:

1322483112.jpg


wikipedia doesn't have a very extensive write-up on this album, but i'm sure most of you are familiar with some of their works. just good tunes to rock out to, all around, particularly:

Under Pressure (there's a vanilla ice shout out there...)
Another One Bites the Dust
Who Wants to Live Forever
Bohemian Rhapsody (a karaoke standard)
Crazy Little Thing Called Love
Radio Ga Ga
We Will Rock You (for when i host sporting events on this imaginary island)
We are the Champions (for when i win said sporting events, since there will be no opponents)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top