Jeeebus, Rust in Peace already? Not on my must have list for this tourney but I thought it might be a good value pick in a late round if I felt I was lacking variety.
Jeeebus, Rust in Peace already? Not on my must have list for this tourney but I thought it might be a good value pick in a late round if I felt I was lacking variety.
I was, and I definitely will be picking some metal, and I recognize that this may just be the finest album in the genre, but still more of a nice to have than a must have for me.If you were a metal fan, as I am, this album would be a must-have. Manowar will come in the later rounds.
Wow, I'm surprised Metallica lasted until the late second round. I'd have bet money someone would have taken them with a first pick.
BTW Slim, this is a great way to pass the time during TDOS, even for us bystandards. Thanks for stealing the idea from wherever you found it.
I'd like to second the motion for a Desert Island Movie Draft too.
Which....video might that be brick? Youtube link? hehe
Okay now peeps -- chop chop! Gadget has her next 18 picks all planned out, and you aren't allowed to take any of them anyway, so let's speed this thing up so we can get back to the important stuff -- namely Gadget's picks.
![]()
Green Day -- Dookie (1994) -- I am imperiling all sorts of extremely important stuff with this pick, and have at least two more that I need to nab in this little snake through my #14/#3 pairing (inded initially this was going to one of the U2 monsters), so I have decided to abuse my moderator powers to give myself a few extra picks this round.But in any case the early/mid-90s are getting worked hard, and so time to step into the arena with another monster from that era -- Green Day's Dookie, which became a flagbearer for the (poppish) punk revival, spawned 5 Top 10, and 3 #1 hits, sold more than 15 million albums worldwide, and has all the normal top all time list/best of accolades of a huge album. The opening chords of When I Come Around are so iconic that even people who have no interest in the style of music know them (if not necessarily knowing where they came from). Followed by Longview, Basket Case, She, Welcome to Paradise...there was a better part of a year there where there was always a Green Day hit on the charts. I know there are other punk bands that you are supposed to take first, but stuck on an island for the rest of my life I'll take the sellouts who can write a pop hook thank you very much.
alright, so i've said this two or three times already in this thread about this being on my list. but i'm f'n serious, for some (obviously misguided) reason i didn't think i'd have competition on this one. this album is so nostalgic, brings back soo many memories. as for green day, for me, IMO, this is by faaaar their best work ever. this is seriously one of my favorite albums ever.
Madonna - Like A Prayer (1989)
I'm not surprised that this has not been taken because i don't think i have the same albums on my list as everyone else.madonna, music icon for so many years and generations, deserves a spot on this hypothetical island.
![]()