Desert Island Music Draft Thread *** draft is over ***

Deset Island Music Draft Finals *** Who Ya Got? ***

  • D-Mass

    Votes: 16 55.2%
  • bozzwell

    Votes: 13 44.8%

  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm gonna pull a pdx and study this round for a day or two before voting. Especially since from my earlier rankings I have clear favorites in each match up. I want to go over those lists in detail and award points and penalties for each pick then see how they stack up.
 
LPKingsFan's recap:

D-Mass v. Bricklayer: Brick's got some good rock in there with Green Day, AC/DC, and Tom Petty, among others. But D-Mass's list is stronger overall, with good mix. Some 90's classics (Oasis, REM, Smashing Pumpkins, Pearl Jam) some all-time classics (Led Zep, The Who and even some more recent hits (Coldplay and Jack Johnson). The Beastie Boys pick is the icing on the cake.

Jerryaki vs. tradepeja: Jerryaki's got some nice contemporary favorites of mine in OutKast, Jack Johnson, and of course, Boyz II Men. But tradepeja's list is one of my favorites in the whole contest: Sublime, The 1967 Beatles (well, minus Rubber Soul I guess), Nirvana (even if I'd prefer the unplugged), Skynyrd, STP, Dr. Dre... I could go on.

bozwell vs. c-diddy: Tough call. c-diddy takes bozwell if you favor 90's rock (which I do at times) coming with Nirvana, Dave Matthews, Counting Crows, Blink.. it's practically 100.5! bozwell, however gets the call with a more diverse mix (even if it's largely absent 90s rock) because it does have The Blue Album and the Bends, some great classic cuts from the Beatles and Stones, and even some good hip hop (the Roots, even if this was one of their weaker efforts, and Public Enemy.

GGG vs. atxrocker: This is probably the hardest decision in the whole shindig. Two great lists, this should be the final, in my opinion... Where to start? On principle, there's no way I should vote against a list that has some of my favorite albums from the Red Hot Chili Peppers, A Tribe Called Quest and my all time favorite, Sublime. In any other matchup, that would be the case. But atxrocker wins my vote with greater depth: not a huge fan of some of GGG's picks, while only two or three of atxrocker's aren't indispensible in my collection. That's an island my ears would enjoy.
 
I'm gonna pull a pdx and study this round for a day or two before voting. Especially since from my earlier rankings I have clear favorites in each match up. I want to go over those lists in detail and award points and penalties for each pick then see how they stack up.
I voted right away this time since my detailed breakdown got deleted the same day I wound up posting it. lol.

But this one was easy for me, I'll actually write up why I voted what I did tomorrow while I have the day off.
 
Only if you think your list is better. ;)
I definitely do, although Jerryaki's list is nothing to sneeze at. I like basically all of it but the Maroon 5 and Boyz II Men.

This is getting hard.....voting against C-Diddy hurt, sucks to run into bozzwell in the 2nd round, I'm sure.

1's and 3's for me.
 
Bricklayer and I both have brutal second round matchups. But hey, I've already exceeded my expectations.

My picks.


D-Mass vs. Brick - D Mass - He was my #1 seed in the pre-rankings. If I had to swap my list for anyone else's, its his, hands down.

Jerriyaki vs. tradepeja - Jerriyaki - A very tough vote for me. Both were in my top five and tradepeja has a really good list. Jerriyaki has a great well rounded list, everything from Eminem to Elvis. A couple picks in there really did it for me though. I love the Ben Folds Five pick and the Jack Johnson pick just fits with the whole Desert Island motif. Great list. I hope I don't have to choose between you and D-Mass. :D

atxrocker vs. GGG - atxrocker - What can I say, he's got Rage, Jimi, Nirvana, 3eb, STP and Radiohead. That's quite a list. Next round is going to be hard for me.

C Diddy vs. Bozzwell. - C Diddy - I shamelessly voted for myself. Not that Bozzwell needs the extra vote anyway. ;)
 

6th

Homer Fan Since 1985
If you haven't yet voted, you could make a difference. It's amazing how close the voting is, so make your voice heard.

Today, Sat, is the final day. Get busy! :p
 
g3 had one of my favorite lists in this draft. going against bozzwell in the next round, not sure what type of support to expect.
That's actually going to be one of the tougher ones for me to judge.

Provided, of course, that I don't throw a hissy fit after losing and protest the whole thing.
 

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
You could always protest the mathematic aberration in this round, since the only pairing atxrocker voted in was between you and he.

;)
 

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
You could always protest the mathematic aberration in this round, since the only pairing atxrocker voted in was between you and he.

;)
atxrocker notified me of his voting error with plenty of advanced notice. The poll has been adjusted to reflect this, not that it changes any results...

Sorry for the delay, but I had a bad case of 'Itis... Semis will be up momentarily.
 

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Desert Island Music Draft *** Semifinals ***

*** Please read the reminder for voting below before casting your vote ***

The original draft thread can be found here .

After adjusting for voters who inadvertently checked the wrong boxes, the final tallies are as follows:

Black Bracket

(1) D-Mass d. (4) Bricklayer: 15-11
(3) tradepeja d. (2) Jerryaki 16-10




Purple Bracket

(1) bozzwell d. (4) C-Diddy 16-10
(3) atxrocker d. (2) GoGoGadget 15-11


Again, both brackets will be voted on in this thread. The bracket winners will be decided upon thusly:

Black Bracket

(1) D-Mass versus (3) tradepeja

Purple Bracket

(1) bozzwell versus (3) atxrocker


Vote for only one list per matchup per bracket.


REMINDER: Because of the way this poll will have to be arranged, you will be required to make multiple votes. The vote will have to be public so that I can keep track of whether anyone makes a double-vote. With regard to this matter, I ask that you pay attention to whom you are voting for: because of the way the multiple vote factors in, it’s possible to accidentally vote for both parties in a given matchup, i.e. accidentally vote for (1) Black and (4) Black. I am including this in the OP with enough advanced notice so that everybody will be aware of what could happen. If, for some reason, you do happen to accidentally vote for both parties in a matchup, PM me before the voting deadline to advise me of the mistake and let me know whom you meant to vote for, and I will correct your vote. Any double votes that I have not been advised of by the voting deadline will be considered invalid, and not counted.
 
Last edited:

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Black Bracket

(1) D-Mass
1.05 - Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin IV - 1971
2.12 - Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream - 1993
3.05 - R.E.M. - Automatic For the People - 1992
4.12 - Pearl Jam - Vs. - 1993
5.05 - Pearl Jam - Vitalogy - 1994
6.12 - The Cranberries - Everybody Else is Doing It, So Why Can't We? - 1993
7.05 - Coldplay - A Rush of Blood to the Head - 2002
8.12 - Beastie Boys - Licensed to Ill - 1986
9.05 - Oasis - (What's the Story) Morning Glory? - 1995
10.12 - Tom Petty - Wildflowers - 1994
11.05 - The Who - Who's Next - 1971
12.12 - Van Halen - MCMLXXXIV - 1984
13.05 - The Samples - The Last Drag - 1993
14.12 - The Boxmasters - The Boxmasters - 2008
15.05 - Sarah McLachlan - Surfacing - 1997
16.12 - Louis Prima -The Wildest! - 1957
17.05 - Jack Johnson - Brushfire Fairytales - 2001
18.12 - Pete Yorn - musicforthemorningafter - 2001
19.05 - Janet Jackson – janet – 1993
20.12 - Madonna - Music - 2000


Versus

(3) tradepeja
1.12 - The Beatles - Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - 1967
2.05 - Nirvana - Nevermind - 1991
3.12 - Dr. Dre - The Chronic 2001 - 1999
4.05 - Lynyrd Skynyrd - (pronounced 'leh-'nérd 'skin-'nérd) - 1973
5.12 - Sublime - Sublime - 1996
6.05 - Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness - 1995
7.12 - 2Pac - Better Dayz - 2002
8.05 - Creedence Clearwater Revival - Cosmo's Factory - 1970
9.12 - Tool - Lateralus - 2001
10.05 - Stone Temple Pilots - Core - 1992
11.12 - Pink Floyd - The Wall - 1979
12.05 - System of a Down - Mesmerize - 2005
13.12 - Kaiser Chiefs - Employment - 2005
14.05 - Stone Sour -Come What(ever) May - 2006
15.12 - Dandy Warhols -Thirteen Tales From Urban Bohemia - 2000
16.05 - N.W.A. -Straight Outta Compton - 1988
17.12 - The Eagles - Hotel California - 1976
18.05 - Foo Fighters - In Your Honor - 2005
19.12 - The Beatles - Magical Mystery Tour - 1967
20.05 - Brian Wilson - SMiLE - 2004
 

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Purple Bracket

(1) bozzwell
1.13 - The Doors - The Doors - 1967
2.04 - The Beach Boys - Pet Sounds - 1966
3.13 - Weezer - Weezer (Blue Album) - 1994
4.04 - Pixies - Doolittle - 1989
5.13 - Bruce Springsteen - Born to Run - 1975
6.04 - The Smiths - The Queen is Dead - 1986
7.13 - The Rolling Stones - Sticky Fingers - 1971
8.04 - The Beatles - Rubber Soul - 1967
9.13 - Queen - A Night at the Opera - 1975
10.04 - Public Enemy - It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back - 1988
11.13 - Radiohead - The Bends - 1995
12.04 - The Roots - The Tipping Point - 2004
13.13 - Stone Roses - Stone Roses - 1989
14.04 - The Strokes -Is This It - 2001
15.13 - Joy Division -Closer - 1980
16.04 - John Coltrane -Giant Steps - 1960
17.13 - Ramones -Ramones - 1976
18.04 - Cocteau Twins - Treasure - 1984
19.13 - The Pogues -Rum, Sodomy & The Lash - 1985
20.04 - New Order -Power, Corruption & Lies - 1983


Versus

(3) atxrocker
1.15 - Rage Against the Machine - The Battle of Los Angeles - 1999
2.02 - The Jimi Hendrix Experience - Electric Ladyland - 1968
3.15 - Nirvana - MTV Unplugged in New York - 1993
4.02 - Wu Tang Clan - Enter the Wu Tang Clan (36 chambers) - 1993
5.15 - Michael Jackson - Bad - 1987
6.02 - Red Hot Chili Peppers - Californication - 1999
7.15 - Outkast - Aquemini - 1998
8.02 - Notorious B.I.G. - Ready to Die - 1994
9.15 - Stone Temple Pilots - Purple - 1994
10.02 - Radiohead - OK Computer - 1997
11.15 - Depeche Mode - Music for the Masses - 1987
12.02 - Lupe Fiasco - Lupe Fiasco's Food & Liquor - 2006
13.15 - Third Eye Blind - Third Eye Blind - 1997
14.02 - Soundgarden - Superunknown - 1994
15.15 - Aceyalone -All Balls Don't Bounce - 1995
16.02 - Eric B & Rakim -Paid in Full - 1987
17.15 - Yeah Yeah Yeah's -Fever to Tell - 2003
18.02 - Lauryn Hill -The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill - 1998
19.15 - Stevie Ray Vaughn and Double Trouble -Texas Flood - 1983
20.02 - Cunninlynguists -A Piece of Strange - 2005
 

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Desert Island Music Draft *** Finals ***

The original draft thread can be found here .

Final tallies are as follows:

Black Bracket

(1) D-Mass d. (3) tradepeja 17-16


Purple Bracket

(1) bozzwell d. (3) atxrocker 17-15 (1 abstaining)


And so, we have reached the Finals... Not the two finalists I would have chosen (it's official: none of you have any rhythm in your souls), but the people have spoken!

(1) D-Mass versus (1) bozzwell




Voting ends next Sunday. And, since there are only two options, this will be a private poll.
 
Last edited:

Mr. S£im Citrus

Doryphore of KingsFans.com
Staff member
Black Bracket Champion

(1) D-Mass
1.05 - Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin IV - 1971
2.12 - Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream - 1993
3.05 - R.E.M. - Automatic For the People - 1992
4.12 - Pearl Jam - Vs. - 1993
5.05 - Pearl Jam - Vitalogy - 1994
6.12 - The Cranberries - Everybody Else is Doing It, So Why Can't We? - 1993
7.05 - Coldplay - A Rush of Blood to the Head - 2002
8.12 - Beastie Boys - Licensed to Ill - 1986
9.05 - Oasis - (What's the Story) Morning Glory? - 1995
10.12 - Tom Petty - Wildflowers - 1994
11.05 - The Who - Who's Next - 1971
12.12 - Van Halen - MCMLXXXIV - 1984
13.05 - The Samples - The Last Drag - 1993
14.12 - The Boxmasters - The Boxmasters - 2008
15.05 - Sarah McLachlan - Surfacing - 1997
16.12 - Louis Prima -The Wildest! - 1957
17.05 - Jack Johnson - Brushfire Fairytales - 2001
18.12 - Pete Yorn - musicforthemorningafter - 2001
19.05 - Janet Jackson – janet – 1993
20.12 - Madonna - Music - 2000


Versus

Purple Bracket Champion

(1) bozzwell
1.13 - The Doors - The Doors - 1967
2.04 - The Beach Boys - Pet Sounds - 1966
3.13 - Weezer - Weezer (Blue Album) - 1994
4.04 - Pixies - Doolittle - 1989
5.13 - Bruce Springsteen - Born to Run - 1975
6.04 - The Smiths - The Queen is Dead - 1986
7.13 - The Rolling Stones - Sticky Fingers - 1971
8.04 - The Beatles - Rubber Soul - 1967
9.13 - Queen - A Night at the Opera - 1975
10.04 - Public Enemy - It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back - 1988
11.13 - Radiohead - The Bends - 1995
12.04 - The Roots - The Tipping Point - 2004
13.13 - Stone Roses - Stone Roses - 1989
14.04 - The Strokes -Is This It - 2001
15.13 - Joy Division -Closer - 1980
16.04 - John Coltrane -Giant Steps - 1960
17.13 - Ramones -Ramones - 1976
18.04 - Cocteau Twins - Treasure - 1984
19.13 - The Pogues -Rum, Sodomy & The Lash - 1985
20.04 - New Order -Power, Corruption & Lies - 1983
 
I've been pretty silent throughout the whole voting process, but I will say this: I'm totally surprised that my list made it to this point, so thank you to those who helped get it here. And thanks again to Slim for making this TDOS go a lot faster...and with a lot more fun. And as Brick said awhile back, it has been nice to learn a bit about music I've never considered before...I plan to check out a lot of the artists recommended in this thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.