I did get the hell out of the kitchen. Then there was one less umpire and as I was good, there was one less good umpire. It becomes a self perpetuating prophecy. As the job becomes less enjoyable, the quality of umpire is lessened. This attitude that it is OK to heckle the kids and heckle the umpires takes the fun out of it. THAT is a reality. Pay me some money and I might be more willing to tolerate it.
If you think I did the job poorly, you are way off. I never had trouble with fans as I could defuse anger. Most of the guys I worked with were very good at it and certainly weren't of the quality that was at the game Jackson attended. I frankly have never heard of a game canceled because of a row between an official and a fan. I am talking about the leagues I umpired in. That's absurd and I have said that before. As people seemingly and perhaps deliberately have an inability to piece together more than one note at a time, I will say it all again. The rules of the organization I umpired specifically called for good behavior by the fans and on a whole, they were great. I don't know when anger and bitching became part of the sport but at the high school level and below I think that that is absurd.
After one game I almost got beaten for the opposing coach's stupidity. It's a long story but it clearly had nothing to do with the quality of the umpires. The coach made a mistake because of his lack of knowledge of the rules and when his team lost, the parents waited after the game in the parking lot to get us. Would it have been OK if I was beaten? Are fans and coaches always right and the officials always wrong? There comes a slippery slope on how much anger is "OK." At the high school level, not much was allowed and the game was not hurt nor do I suspect fans felt cheated because they had to watch the game and not pick on umpires. Think of the level we are talking about. We are assuming Bobby was correct. He may have been but that's a helluva assumption.
No, I didn't tolerate grief but I never kicked anyone out of a game. Between innings I would talk to the person who was over amped and calm him down. It always worked. Other umpires handled the problems differently but the games flowed and the tempers were under control. The demeanor of the official has a lot to do with how the game goes. In the case we are talking about (Bobby), both seemed to be looking for a fight and as I have said over and over, the game shouldn't have been stopped. If I was the chief official of that league, I'd have a serious discussion with the official involved.
I took on the job because of the kids. Novel concept. It never came naturally but I was good.
We all read into the story what we wish. No one has mentioned that not all parents agreed with Bobby. No one has mentioned that Bobby's son called him "intimidating." Nobody mentioned that Bobby's son was not allowed to be on camera. The only time I saw an entire team's parents go on the attack was when the coach was out of control. The fans look for a leader and then pack mentality takes over. When the umpire/referee becomes more of interest than the kids, something has been lost and I fault all sides on that. It's a two way street and people are acting like it is open season on officials and one note says it is OK to heckle the kids. Really??? When do we start heckling kids? When they are 10? When the are 12? When they are 15? When they are 18? I don't think it is ever right to heckle kids and if that started, I would defend the kid. I never saw it however. Maybe Carmichael is just too pleasant and well mannered.
If you can't understand that open season on officials mean that fewer people will be officials, you are being deliberately dull. Making the environment bad for everybody discourages quality players and officials from taking part. That should never be a goal whether intended or not.
Edit: as a fan I was not nice although I tried very hard to realize these officials are not pros and should not be held to the standards of professional officials who have enough troubles. (Did you know that the best NBA refs are right just a little over 90% of the time?) I was right on the edge and if the refs were incompetent, I had to bite my lip and didn't succeed all the time. We are dealing with humans who have taken on a thankless job and I hope fans understand that.