Some rumors that I heard, and bear in mind, these are like third party rumors. The Kings were very impressed with Payton in the workout. They thought Smart was a little overweight, and implied that Payton may have outplayed Smart in head to head, whatever that means. One unnamed official said the Kings might even consider drafting Payton at 8. (I have trouble believing that) It was also rumored that the Kings have zero interest in Smart, who they think is too much like Evans, who they didn't think was a good fit. Sounds a little made up to me, and if true, it could also be a smoke screen. I mean if they have zero interest, then why bring him in for a workout. They were also impressed with Vonleh. Not so much with Ennis, whose PG skills they like, but question his ability to defend.
Obviously everything has to be taken with more than a grain of salt at this point in the process but if we were looking for an explanation as to why the Kings brought in Smart if it's the case that they don't really like his game then it's not hard to concoct a plausible one. Whether Smart can run a team or not, he has elite size & strength for a PG and is a top tier college defender. It only makes sense to see guys like Ennis and Peyton go against him. And likewise to see how they guard a physically imposing guard, especially Ennis who was never forced to defend man-to-man due to Syracuse's zone D.
Plausible? Who knows? But I would say that if the Kings are really as keen on trading the pick as they seem to indicate then why wouldn't the smoke screen be that they absolutely loved Smart? And Vonleh for that matter? I would think that the FO would be looking to hype up the players (and the team's interest in them) that are projected to be around when the Kings are on the clock.
I'm largely on the same page with you regarding Smart and Tyreke. Not a great comparison other than that both guys got moved to the PG position and have great size for that spot. Tyreke has one of the best handles in the NBA and I'd argue he's got the best handle of anybody his size. Smart is a capable handler but not in the same league. Tyreke was impossibly shifty with great body control when attacking the rim whereas Smart is a bowling ball. Defensively Smart is better by simple virtue of his dedication on that end. Evans flashed the potential of being a very good defender but never made the concerted effort to be great. And that's the one reason I could see Smart being better than Evans. To me Tyreke was a far better prospect entering the NBA but I just never saw a killer instinct and/or the will to be great out of him. Smart might be mentally stronger/tougher and have more desire to improve. They won't be similar players and as prospects I was much more impressed with Evans but at the NBA level the separation between good and great has so much to do with putting in the work to improve and Smart could potentially have a big edge there. We'll see.
How much is true is debatable. One thing that may be true is that they really like Payton, who apparently impressed them a lot. Personally, I think they have their sights set on Gordon. Why bring him for a secret meeting with Vivek. No one would have known if not for a national writer who somehow found out about it, and asked the other journalists where Gordon was at the workout. I think there's a lot of smoke and mirrors going on.
I don't see the fit for Gordon. If Gay returns he'd be forced to get most of his minutes at the PF spot which he's not built to defend right now and doesn't have the weak side defense or rebounding to really be a good fit next to Cuz. If Gay leaves then you have Gordon and Williams fighting it out to start at the SF spot. Obviously Gordon gives you a lot more defensively at the 3 but offensively both guys are athletic, inconsistent and not much else. Just like Randle, I like Gordon just not on this Kings team led by DeMarcus Cousins.
I'd be very okay with Payton though. Especially if the Kings could pry Sanders from Milwaukee for expiring contracts or enders plus JT or Landry. If the Cavs pass on Embiid and the Bucks nab him I think Sanders becomes that much more available and I'd much prefer the Kings gambling on Larry returning to form than drafting Vonleh (or Randle) or giving up a ton to get Kevin Love.
Payton
McLemore
Gay
Sanders
Cousins
Is a nice core to me. I'd love to have IT back. He would take pressure of Payton having to start right away and then (assuming Payton develops into a quality player) Thomas would be an elite sixth man. Add in a guy like Anthony Morrow to back up McLemore at the SG spot and I'd feel pretty good about how that team would fare next year and over the next four or five years.