Well this is interesting.
First of all let me just confirm my macho guy credentials...er...let's go with: I had my jaw broken playing football in law school. I finished the rest of the game (happend in first quarter) spitting up blood. Then I went to the rest of my classes that day with an icebag on the jaw. Then I went into the bathroom to spit up some more blood and noticed that when I pressed on the right side of my jaw, the whole lower jaw shifted over to the left out of alignment with the top jaw. I decided this was a bad sign. So I walked over to the hospital and had to stay overnight so they could set the jaw and wire it shut for 6 weeks. Then after 4 weeks I demanded they take the wires off because I had a debate that week and needed to be able to speak clearly. I'm tough damnit!!! REALLY tough! GRRRRRR!!!!!!!
That said, the interesting thing is that I have been effected by a high percentage of the same movies that have been mentioned here. Not sure whether I ever actually cry over anything (movies or not), but tearing up/lump in throat is possible:
Bambi's Mom -- when I was a kid did it (of course I also got a hoot out of Bambi vs. Godzilla so not sure what it means)
ET dying -- when I was about 11 or so
Ghost -- the ending.
Return of the King
several points in The Fellowship of the Ring
Gladiator (end)
Field of Dreams may have, not sure
Armageddon end death of Bruce
And also now that I think about it:
end sequence of Dances with Wolves came close
the Armageddon moment in Deep Impact (where they sacrifice themselves to save Earth)
the finale episode of Babylon 5 called "Sleeping in Light" -- amazingly poetic end
But I'm tough damnit! And if anyone here tells anyone about this I will kick their ***!!!