The thing about playing Evans at PG (and I'm just randomly choosing this topic instead of the 12 or so others discussing the same thing ) is that even if he isn't in traditional terms a PG, his primary strength is breaking down defense man-to-man and getting into the lane, and for that to happen he needs the ball in his hands. If you get a pass-first PG and move Evans to the SG spot, your PG is going to be handling the ball and Evans' most tangible strength on the basketball court has been neutralized. So if you're banking on Evans' becoming a star, than you really do have to go all-in with his style of play and give him the ball. Whether you call him a PG or a SG doesn't really matter. Call him a guard and be done with it. Regardless of who else is in the backcourt with him, he needs to be the primary ball-handler on offense, if not for the whole game, than at least for the fourth quarter.
Lebron James, Dwayne Wade, and Brandon Roy are all similar players who can create shots for themselves or for others but they need the ball in their hands to make their impact. None of them is a PG, and they've been paired up with more traditional PGs who become mostly spot shooters in their offense. Portland lets Blake share PG responsibilities throughout the game but they give Roy the ball to close the game. Cleveland and Miami do the same thing to a lesser extent. Kobe is different because he can still be effective as a jump-shooter, but even LA goes to a Kobe-dominated offense to close the game.
That's the type of player that Evans is. Whether he'll be as succesful as the afformentioned players depends on the extent to which he has the court vision, killer instinct, work ethic, and physical gifts to make it work. Those are all subjective and still developing. But my point is that having a player like that on the floor greatly diminishes the need for a traditional PG, regardless of what position you want to put them at. And the number of players that can do what they do succesfully in the NBA (basically score at will) is so small that you really have to thank your lucky stars if you're lucky enough to get one.
Lebron James, Dwayne Wade, and Brandon Roy are all similar players who can create shots for themselves or for others but they need the ball in their hands to make their impact. None of them is a PG, and they've been paired up with more traditional PGs who become mostly spot shooters in their offense. Portland lets Blake share PG responsibilities throughout the game but they give Roy the ball to close the game. Cleveland and Miami do the same thing to a lesser extent. Kobe is different because he can still be effective as a jump-shooter, but even LA goes to a Kobe-dominated offense to close the game.
That's the type of player that Evans is. Whether he'll be as succesful as the afformentioned players depends on the extent to which he has the court vision, killer instinct, work ethic, and physical gifts to make it work. Those are all subjective and still developing. But my point is that having a player like that on the floor greatly diminishes the need for a traditional PG, regardless of what position you want to put them at. And the number of players that can do what they do succesfully in the NBA (basically score at will) is so small that you really have to thank your lucky stars if you're lucky enough to get one.