I appreciate that you've moved some from your stance in the other thread that Bill Laimbeer was a singular talent, but the only championship Ben Wallace has ever won was alongside a 6'11" "forward" who had the option of either posting up or shooting a three. Sheed is currently with Boston, where he's coming off the bench to spell KG and Perkins, shooting an average of 6 threes a game(!)
We have a similar dynamic as Detroit here, with JT as the garbageman and Spencer... well...
The problem with Spencer this season isn't shot selection, it's sucking. I hope he works his way out of it, but whether he's posting up, or shooting stupid jumpshots, he's missing and turning the ball over. An ideal Spencer would space the floor on one possession, and punish people inside on another, but that's not what we have this season. Instead we have another garbageman, who shows a lot of hustle, and few of the skills (interior or exterior) that made him so intriguing as a prospect.
I haven't moved from my stance at all. You introduced PFs, and sorry, that's a fail argument too. Even including PFs, so now taking the ENTIRE FRONTCOURTS of every champinship team in the last 29 years since the 3pt shot was invented? Do you know how many 3pt shooting bigs there have been in the starting lineups of those championship teams?
Three.
Bill Laimbeer, an old groundbound thug who found a way to extend his career by doing something freaky.
Rasheed Wallace, who won a single title for a one hit wonder team after playing half a year in Detroit, and actually was one of the best post players of his era when he wasn't farting around at the 3pt line. Ask Detroit whetehr his contribution was his 3pt shooting or his post play.
And Robert Horry, a clutch roleplaying SF who twice was called upon to play 25min a night roleplaying starter next to all time legendary centers (who did not shoot threes BTW) -- once for half a season in Houston next to Hakeem after Otis Thorpe was traded away for Clyde Drexler, once next to Shaquille O'Neal assuming the spot held down by ancient AC Green and Horace Grant the previous two championship years. Both seasons it should be noted his teams had won the title the year beforehand, so you can hardly say his presence and shooting put them over the top.
There's your grand total. If anything it strengthens the 3pt shooting bigs are garbage argument, because more PFs than Cs shoot them around the league, and yet they just DO NOT WIN TITLES. And the handful of times they have they have been playing alongside all time monster defender/rebounders who can cover for their pansieness (what they are trying to do down in Orlando of course) and could have won it with almsot anybody. You introduced an entire different positon to the argument (and a different one from what Spencer plays) and got 3 shaky seasons out of it, two of them half seasons, two of them for teams that had already won the title the year before, one for a one hit wonder freak team that had precedent neither before nor after, and all three playing next to all time great physcial beasts at center.
So now here's our all time list of championship starting frontcourts since the three point line was invented. Three point shooters will be in red. Wusses would be in pink, except there haven't been any. Maybe Buddha Edwards.
2009 -- Bynum/Gasol
2008 -- Perkins/Garnett
2007 -- Oberto/Duncan
2006 -- Shaq/Haslem
2005 -- Rasho/Duncan
2004 -- Wallace/
Wallace (half year)
2003 -- Robinson/Duncan
2002 -- Shaq/
Horry
2001 -- Shaq/Grant
2000 -- Shaq/Green
1999 -- Robinson/Duncan
1998 -- Longley/Rodman
1997 -- Longley/Rodman
1996 -- Longley/Rodman
1995 -- Hakeem/
Horry (half year)
1994 -- Hakeem/Thorpe
1993 -- Cartwright/Grant
1992 -- Cartwright/Grant
1991 -- Cartwright/Grant
1990 --
Laimbeer/Edwards(Rodman/Salley -- platoon)
1989 --
Laimbeer/Edwards(Rodman/Salley -- platoon)
1988 -- Abdul Jabbar/Green
1987 -- Abdul Jabbar/Green
1986 -- Parish/McHale
1985 -- Abdul Jabbar/Rambis
1984 -- Parish/McHale (Greg Kite might have been spot starting, forget)
1983 -- Malone/Jones
1982 -- Abdul Jabbar/Rambis
1981 -- Parish/Maxwell
1980 -- Abdul Jabbar/Chones
You could hardly have hit upon a trait LESS attached to title winning than 3pt shooting bigs. You would have been better off arguing for bigs who like to put ketchup on their eggs or who have warts on their *** in the shape of Texas.
You mention spacing. Sure. 16-18 feet is all you have ever needed out of a big. Its all you've needed for 30 years of title teams. You also mention roleplayers off the bench. And again, sure. If you want to have a 4th big who can come in occasionally and matchup with a three, some teams have done that. Normally a 3/4. A bench player who might average 8pts a game or some such and present a different look. But that's what you are talking about here. A roleplayer carried tot he title by guys who play it straight. Championship bigs do not shoot threes. They just don't. They battle inside. If they have post game, they use it. If they don't, then they set screens, crash the glass, move to the hoop to take pases off of guard penetration, and do a variety of other useful things that you can't do camped out at the three point line.