Kingster
Hall of Famer
This is coming at the whole 17 win thing from the wrong direction. Other than the dubiousness of a GM not knowing himself how his team would perform. I have mentioned several times before that I took Hollinger to task for saying we'd win 23 -- think my own prediction was 30-32.
But the fact is that we are far BETTER off now, because Geoff didn't know what the hell he had wrought. If Geoff had KNOWN he had put together a 17win squad last year I would have lauded him for it. Finally a rebuild, a shot at a top pick, and a chance at the future. The problem isn't that he put together a 17 win team, the problem was that he INTENDED to put together a 30-35 win team. Anyone who intends to do that, with old vets littering the roster to boot, just deserves to be slapped. That is the absolute armpit of all aspirations. And to continue to do it after year after year of grinding decline and mediocrity...that's just asinine.
His tacit admission that maybe there's an argument for starting the rebuild earlier (really Geoff? duh), but that he, or they, couldn't bring himself to do it, was more revelatory.
Totally agree. Petrie (and we fans) lucked out because his team was a lot worse than what he thought. As a result of his fortune, he got Tyreke Evans, who could be the best player in the draft. His mediocre vet/youngins schitzo approach to cobble together 30-35 wins was totally repudiated by what happened last season. Finally, Petrie said, "Uncle!" and gave in to reality. And that's exactly when we hit bottom.