This sentence is our fundemental difference. You are implying that the market value of a guy in his prime could be a pay cut unless I miss the point. That's insulting to a lot of players and to me it doesn't make sense. A guy who is 29-30 is probably not going to get a whole lot better but certainly is not going to get worse in the immediate future. He offers veteran leadership, something that has value to Cuz. Watch their relationship when they are on the bench. These guys like each other. Let us not forget the Cuz problem as perhaps Dally has been a great help to him.
Long story short - signing Dally gives us Dally and may help Cuz which is a good thing.
I'm not picking a number because that isn't my point. Well, not my entire point.

At a certain point it IS silliness but I don't think that is going to happen. No one has a lot of cap space to get into a bidding war. Some teams have cap space but I count on Dally wishing to stay here because of relationships developed especially with Cuz. He certainly can see the future of this team and if he has an ego, his stay here could do for him what the Kings did for Webber except on a smaller level. Otherwise put, he may become the best player he can be by staying here. He said he likes Westphal because Westphal has encouraged him to play a little offense. He said no other coach has asked anything of him but to block shots and rebound. Name a player who doesn't like to score and who would like it if he was told to not even try. So there is an intangible non-monetary appeal to staying here.
And there are the fans.
Of course we pay market price but I have seen suggestions that he should get $4-8 mil per year or in that ball park. I think the man who he is, the fact he is in his prime and has proven to be a far greater addition to this team than we expected, we do what we can to keep him. I don't know where my cut off point is because it depends on other signings especially the free agent market.
I doubt if he'd demand a raise but we'll find out and until we sign him, because of the mysteries of the effect his salary has on our cap space, I hope we settle quickly with him.
To make my point, I wouldn't fight over a million dollars.