1. It seems like in evluating production you are only looking at raw stats and not interested in pace or minutes played, right?
2. You favor the eye test. Well, fair enough, but I would like to know the last few freshman bigs who had impact in college in your eyes? I hope you didn't expect to see 7 year NBA veteran instead of college freshman and I don't think it's fair to expect said college freshman to play with the same poise as 22-year old junior or 27-year old senior. Though I saw a few Florida St games I wasn't looking at James at all but in Kansas games I don't recall Withey to go out to the perimeter and not look like fish out of the water. Drummond didn't look lost. It's very much relevant in the pros.
1.) To be honest I rarely look at college player's stats. And usually just to verify what I'm seeing. So for instance if someone tells me that player X is a bad 3-point shooter, and I watch 10 games and I see this player knocking down 3s at a good clip, I'll take a look at the stats. See if perhaps the player shot poorly but has improved their 3-pt shot as they develop their over-all game.
This is just an example btw. I don't really care how many points a player has at the end of the day, but rather, are they able to get good scoring opportunities, and will those scoring opportunities translate to the next level.
I'm not a fan of Sullinger because I'm skeptical that he'll be able to translate his fantastic post-game to the NBA. So he is productive in college, but I'll be surprised if he can continue that at the NBA level.
2.) And yes, I do favor the eye-test. When you're watching college players, that's really all you can do, because nothing is guaranteed at the next level.
And I think it is fair to say that evaluating a college players defensive and rebounding potential in college is infinitely easier than judging a college player's offensive potential.
If a player is able to dominate in rebounding and defense, it's easier to see that sort of stuff translate to the NBA. MKG is going to be a great defender as will Jeff Taylor. When Aaron Craft comes out (probably next year) he's going to be a phenominal defensive PG. Anthony Davis is going to be a great defender.
Henson is will be a good defender if he can put on weight. (I don't think he will, which is why I don't think he'll ultimately be a good defender at the PF position)
You could tell that Favors was going to be a good defensive player even though his year at G.Tech wasn't that great.
I wasn't at all surprised about Faried this year. I loved him last year, and his heart, hustle, energy, and rebounding all translated.
I was watching Drummond from a defensive/rebounding/energy perspective, and not so much an offensive perspective. His offensive game was mediocre last season, but that didn't bother me all that much. What bothered me was the lack of energy/hustle/rebounding he displayed.
He averaged 28 min/game but ended up with barely over 4 defensive rebounds a game. Since we know that he's an explosive athlete with good length, that speaks directly to his energy/hustle.
Let's me be clear here. I'm not saying that he's going to be a bust by any means. What I am saying is that there was a huge difference between the kid's performance his last year in High School and his performance in college.
He wasn't an impact player in college, and therefore I'm not going to say definitively that he's going to hit that switch and turn it all around in the NBA. He may very well hit that switch and compete at the next level due to his understanding that he has to put everything he has into the game in order to impact it at the highest levels.
So if Petrie thinks this kid can flip the switch and become an impact player on the court, I'll be rooting heavily for this kid's success. But if we pass on him I won't be surprised.
I should mention that the best day I've had in years as a sports fan was the day Demarcus slipped past the Wolves and we took him with the 5th pick. In that case I know people were concerned about his character issues, but I would never had forgiven Petrie for passing up on Demarcus.
With Drummond it's a different situation, and if we pass on him, regardless of how Drummond performs in the future, I'll understand exactly where Petrie is coming from.