vj9999 said:#1 Thanks for calling me out.
#2 I think I built mycredibility around here that I don't wear any player "lens". I will blindely defend any player on this team when they are being singled out.
#3 Are you telling me that picking up 5 PFs and playing agreassive like he did tonight is not a sign of good defending?
I'm off to clean my lenses.
Singled out for what? An A?
I wasn't challenging your credibility. And you use the term rather loosely because credibility is usually applied to factual claims (like say if you give out second-hand info on player quotes). We're arguing over pure opinion. I was challenging your assertion that he played good defense. He played defense well enough that I don't think he should be docked imaginary player grade points for it.
The #3 is funny. By that logic, any scrub can come in, pick up 5 fouls on Shaq, and therefore, has played great defense. It may or may not mean he played aggressively. Because I watched how he played and how he picked up his fouls, I am confident in saying he was aggressive. It's not because I looked at his stats and saw he had 5 fouls which is not really an indicator of anything interesting.