10,000 Manicas -- 10,000 Maniacs, MTV Unplugged (1993)
Well this was going to be a late round special, but with people suddenly remembering the Unplugged series, as well as encroaching on indie rock (Pixies), I decided that I had better fire this one up before somebody remembered it. This might have been the best of the entire unplugged series IMO. And a major part of that was because the Maniacs sounded like, well, the Maniacs. Which is to say a sophisticated indie rock band that was actually, you know, listenable. Lacking pretension, they actually deigned to write hooks and had one hell of a lead singer. For this show they brought all their instruments and hired about a dozen outside muscians for the show, and had violas, cellos, slide guitars, mandolins, organs, multiple drumsets, and everything else that they needed to duplicate their lush, complex sound on the live stage. And then of course there was Natalie Merchant, who always had a tremendously rich and powerful voice, and sounded every bit as good live as she did in studio. In any case, this live acoustic album was immensely successful, charted up into the Top 20, and contained versions of all of their best songs (Trouble Me, These Are the Days etc. -- in fact the best versions of most of them), as well as a great cover of the old Springsteen song "Because the Night" that became the biggest hit in the band's history. It was their peak performance, and also their swan song, as Natalie left the next year to pursue a solo career. Funny that this is the first album with a female lead singer to make my list -- I generally prefer them to men, and I played this album incessantly back in my college days.