All the albums I've drafted so far, I really, really like. But this might be the first one I've been able to get to my island that I absolutely love.
Jar of Flies - Alice in Chains (1994)
The story behind Jar of Flies is such perfect "mystic rock legend" I almost have trouble believing it as anything more than exceedingly clever marketing. The band came home from a world tour in support of their second album to find themselves evicted having not paid rent while on tour. Naturally, they decided to live in their studio temporarily and over the course of a week long jam session produced this "hauntingly gorgeous" and, at times, serenely dark gem. Of course they never intended to release the album and just considered it "four guys getting together in the studio making some music." But their label really liked what they heard, released it as Jar of Flies and whaddya know, it debuted at #1 on the Billboard 200.
I honestly don't remember how I came across this. It wasn't taken in the last draft (Edit: Just discovered Dirt was, in fact, taken last time.), and while I grew up cognizant of the Seattle grunge explosion of the early 90s, AiC was drowned out by the likes of Nirvana and Pearl Jam to the point I'm not sure I even knew they existed.
But I do remember the first time I heard the opening bass line (I looked that up
) of Rotten Apple and being immediately drawn in. If I try to talk too much about the structure or craftsmanship, my musical ignorance will reveal itself, so I'll let the songs speak for themselves.
Rotten Apple
Rotten Apple hypnotized me into a blissful stupor and at the 1:40 mark of Nutshell (specifically), I was hooked.
Nutshell -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDW4ARh9_4o
And those are two of the only three songs out of the album's seven not released as singles. It gets decidedly more upbeat (or at least less suffocatingly depressing) after that with singles chart toppers No Excuses and I Stay Away leading into the string instrumental (that's right) Whale & Wasp, before winding things down with the respectably successful, soulful single Don't Follow and, of all things, the blues/country-inspired closing track Swing on This.
There's so much going on here, so many different styles and approaches to music. Every song is its own, unique entity, but they all work as a cohesive thematic unit as well. It clocks in a just over a half hour and yet I could listen to it on repeat constantly.
Interestingly, Jar of Flies' release is sandwiched by Alice in Chains monster albums that, having decided to be the first to introduce AiC into our draft, might garner me more votes. But as I said, this is the one I love.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jar_of_Flies
P.S. The Jar of Flies title refers to an elementary school science experiment AiC's guitarist Jerry Cantrell had as a kid. Two jars of flies, one overfed, the other underfed. The first flourished for a short while before quickly dying out from overpopulation. The last survived the entire course of the class. Quote Layne Staley: "I guess there's a message in there somewhere."