nbrans
All-Star
captain bill said:Most PGs are subpar defenders. We just happen to have one that is subpar even for a PG. I'm sure if we had a good defensive scheme and good players on the court we could be a good team on D in spite of Bibby.
See, I don't buy into this idea that teams can afford to have a subpar defender at the point guard position. A good interior defense can compensate for some weak defending on the perimeter and a shotblocker can discourage penetration, but I think that the point guard position is arguably the most important cog in any defensive team.
In most offenses in the league, basically any offense other than the triangle (Lakers) and its variants (Kings), the point guard is responsible for creating most of the offense. A good defensive point guard can not only slow down the Marburys and Nashs of the world, but they can also disrupt offensive rhythm and make it more difficult for the entire rest of the team to get good looks. If you look at recent championship teams, they have all had a good defensive point guard. (Parker, Billups, Fisher, Avery Johnson, Ron Harper, etc.)
I think that if the Kings are going to be a serious defensive team, one way to do that would be to trade Bibby. With the Kings' current offense and its current roster, I don't know that Bibby's offense is so essential that the Kings really need to keep him. With the passing and ball movement offense, the Kings don't rely on Bibby to penetrate and create offense, and so for the most part he's just an initiator and a jump shooter. Both are qualities that are replacable.
Trading Bibby would not only open up the point guard position for a defensive point guard like Jason Hart, who is a capable jump shooter, a solid offensive initiator and a good defender, it could also bring in a young power forward who could help out on the interior. I know Bibby's clutchness and willingness to take big shots is important, but if people on this board are really serious about the Kings getting better defensively I think it's time to stop making excuses for Bibby and to realize that trading him is the best chance to get someone like Tyson Chandler.