rhythmless
Starter
Lets see here.....why don't we compare a 5th year NBA player (player A) to a 2nd year player (player B).
1) Player A has 3 full NBA seasons to develop when the lock out shortened season happened that welcomed player B to his rookie year.
2) Player A is on his 3rd NBA team having played for a pretty good variety of coaches. Including one who is HOF as a player. Player B has been in Sacto playing for the Maloofs and Smart.
3) Player A was known as a defensive force in college. Player B was an offensive force in college.
IMHO we are comparing apples to oranges here. I like both these guys and they are definitely at different stages of development with Toney having a 3 year edge in age and NBA experience.
KB
Its not quite as disparate a comparison as you make it out to be. Td is older, but a far more polished defensive player. Sometimes that may be what this team needs at that moment. Jimmer is basically useless unless he's jacking up a shot. Can't handle under pressure, can't score inside. Hell, he rarely gets a layup off fast breaks because the defender can catch up so quickly.
I get that Jimmer is younger, but as a coach, you still have to think game by game and go with results for that game. Other players don't give a crap how old you are. The basketball doesn't care how old you are, and neither does the hoop. Age is no crutch. Fix your weaknesses and perform, or get the hell out because someone else will do the job.