Didn't actually mean it as a negative, lol. I mean Bradley did PLAY in the NBA coming from a lesser NCAA school. Petrie was really high on him! Just saying the odds of a big man coming out of those divisions has never been great for determining success, and I thought Bradley was a no-brainer 10 year NBA'er. I was wrong. Hopefully I'm wrong about Muscala too, for the opposite reasons.
I like his motor and hustle for a big, he really does a nice job at closing out on shooters in the 10-15 foot range. He blocks out, which is a rare skill these days. My biggest concern is his little jump hooks, which worked great in college, but I have my doubts they will work as well in the NBA because of his release point. He didn't really shoot a great % either for a dominate big.
His best chance to make it is as a system player and finding the right fit. If he can develop a NBA 3 point shot that will help a ton too. As we've heard in workouts, he can really shoot it, but it will have to translate to live game situations (see Douby, Q).
I actually mean't my post to be a little humorous, but I forgot to put the little smiley face. Your concern about his little hookshots, which he shoots with either hand is legit. But just about every player coming into the NBA has to make adjustments to his game. Muscala has been a good shooter throughout his college career, and he showed range all the way out to just inside the three point line, so I feel confident he'll be able to extend his range a bit futher. But even if not, you have to guard him. As you pointed out, he's an excellent rebounder and some of that is that he's fundamentally sound. He battles for position and blocks out. He needs to get stronger, but he's legit size, and we need more size on this team.
You got me thinking about players that came from mid-level conferences and were successful. So I did a little digging and came up with a few that were notable. By notable, I don't necessarily mean stars, but players that had solid NBA careers. I only included forwards and centers. The list would have been much longer had I included guards with players like Steve Nash, John Stockton and Walt Frazier heading the list.
Theo Ratliff: University of Wyoming
Willis Reed: Grambling
Truck Robinson: Tennessee St.
Jeff Ruland: Iona
Bill Russell: USF
Dennis Rodman: Southeastern Oklahoma St.
Robery Parish: Centenary College
Scottie Pippin: University of Central Arkansas
John Saley: Georgia Institute of Technology
Purvis Short: Jackson St.
Paul Sillas: Creighton
Jack Sikma: Illinois Wesleyan University
Rik Smits: Marist College
Maurice Stokes: Saint Francis University
Nate Thurmond: Bowling Green
Ben Wallace: Virginia Union
Kermit Washington: American University
Mark West: Old Dominion
Charles Oakley: Virginia Union
Hakeem Olajuwon: University of Houston
Jawann Oldham: Seattle University
Michael Olowokandi: UOP
Bo Outlaw: University of Houston
Greg Foster: University of Texas at El Paso
Jeff Foster: Southwestern Texas St.
Adonal Foyle: Colgate
Chris Gatling: Old Dominion
Artis Gilmore: Jacksonville University
Mike Farmer: USF
Kenneth Faried: Moorehead St.
Stephen Jackson: Butler County community college
Popeye Jones: Murray St.
Believe me, there are more, but I got tired of looking for them. I don't know what the percentage of failure rate is compared to the major conferences, but it wouldn't surpirse me if it was a better success rate than the majors Nothing to back it up though.