So he's going to start hitting his outside shot with another team? He's going to develop a killer instinct with another team? He's going to be consistent every night and not have a horrible game every third game? Is another team going to let him be the full time PG so he can go 20/5/5 again, only to lose 70% of the time? I understand that the Kings might not be getting the best out of him right now but his limitations and deficiencies will be evident on other teams as well. In my opinion, it really all depends on who we get back if we trade him. If we ended up with the 6-8 pick and we could trade him and the pick to get Davis I'd do it and not even blink an eye. The problem is I don't think there would be a GM in the league except for maybe Michael Jordan who would accept that deal.
Mm. Problem is ... we let IT be our full time PG and we lose what % of the time? So perhaps the problem is not Tyreke at PG, or IT at PG, but something else. Like coaching ...
I think Tyreke's progress is like this:
- Splendid rookie season
- Disappointing sophomore season, injury as valid excuse.
- Expectation to come into 3rd season healthy and playing well with a jumpshot (consistency was never a question prior to this season). Reports of a much improved jumpshot during the offseason.
- Started 3rd season poorly under Westphal. Started playing very well under Smart who was developing at PG but jumper seemed to get worse as season progressed.
- Moved to SF when we annointed IT the new savior of the franchise. Expected to play off the ball.
- Is rarely given the ball in a half court offense, with Thomas preferring to swing the ball to the other side or pass to bigs.
- Results in Tyreke looking lost, games where he only takes 5 or 6 shots
So I guess the point is you really don't know that he won't start hitting his outside shot with another team, that he won't become a consistent player. It doesn't have to be at the PG position mind you, but he needs to be given the ball. Oscar Robertson called him unguardable, yet Smart wants him to play off the ball, stand in the corner on offense, and focus on defense, like some sort of Bruce Bowen or Shane Battier. No one calls those guys unguardable. Why in the world his improved jumpshot doesn't seem to carry on throughout the season is beyond me, but now he's shown that he's going to work on it in the offseason. The main thing is that we cannot give up on him just yet. Let him have another offseason with a clearly defined role in mind, ensure that he is getting enough touches on the offensive end in areas where he can put his skills to work. Don't just throw the guy into the fire and say ok now you have to play off the ball or you won't score at all.
I have long said that if by the trade deadline next season he still isn't the player we want him to be then we should by all means trade him and not look back.