The difference is in the overall talent. Hawes and JT put together will never reach the same level that Bosh is at. He is a perennial all-star and has been since his 3rd year in the league, something that Hawes and JT will never be.
It's not just about talent though, it's about the kind of talent. Do you think the wizards, warriors, clippers, or raptors lack talent? No. They lack the right kind of talent. Look at Bosh's team. They have talent, and Bosh is having a career year, but they aren't winning (their record is 11-17). Why? Primarily because despite their offensive prowess, they are one of the worst defensive teams in the league. All that firepower doesn't matter.
Again, despite Bosh's superior talent, is he going to help the kings? Do the kings need help on offense? Or, do they need to improve where they are deficient? They are currently 5th in the NBA in scoring, averaging nearly 105 PPG. That's top 5, behind the Hawks, Warrios, Nuggets, and Suns. Does adding Bosh and his offense really make the team better? What kind of team do you want to see?
For me, I see this team's turnaround from these main reasons:
- effort
- improved defense/rebounding
- coaching
- talent
Last season, there was talent, but the other factors were missing, and we watched a 17 win season. Talent doesn't = contenders.
So the question I think that matters is this: do you sacrifice the direction of the team in order to add more talent, no matter if it's the wrong kind of talent or not? Having seen current teams in that situation, I think no. I think if you want to add talent, then fine, but make it the kind that improves your team the most. Is Bosh a good big man? Yes. Is he better than Hawes or JT? Yes. Do I think his superior offensive talent will make the kings into contenders? No.
I just cannot understand how people cannot see that you can build a conteder around Evans and Bosh for years to come. Its a perfect inside-outside duo and if you surround them with the right role players you are contending for the next decade or so.
Because if that were the case, then Bosh would have contended before. In his 6 seasons, he's made the playoffs twice and lost both times in the first round.
I just cannot understand how people cannot see that it takes more than all star selections to build a contender. Too many times I have seen good players struggle to win because of the wrong teammates or the wrong coach.
Would I trade JT or Hawes straight up for Bosh? Yeah, in a second. But it doesn't make the Kings contenders. It doesn't solve their problems. It just means they score more while still giving up plays inside, and still getting out muscled against the better teams down low. Is that the style that works? Is it why the team is changing direction? Are the raptors the team you want to watch because of their offense?