Tropical Island IPOD Singles Draft Thread - Pending playoffs

Status
Not open for further replies.
pdxKingsFan

pdxKingsFan

So Ordinary That It's Truly Quite Extraordinary
Staff member
#36
#36
I don't text either, my wife just goes around saying "I heart" everything. And for the record she's not 15.
 
Kingzrool

Kingzrool

Starter
#47
#47
pdxKingsFan said:
I mean if an artist records a 30 minute extended live version of a 3 minute song from their first album, those are two completely different songs.
Click to expand...
Same title, same song.

pdxKingsFan said:
What about when an artist re-imagines an earlier song with a new title, but its still basically the same song, just updated for modern times? But it has a new title, so its a new song, right?
Click to expand...
Different title, different song.
(this one may be over ridden in extreme circumstances)

pdxKingsFan said:
What about a band that does a live version of 2-3 songs rolled into one (happens quite a lot)... are all the originals off the table after that?
Click to expand...
I see the value in allowing segue's/medley's, and actually thought about it a bit and how guidelines could be put forth. I ended up deciding that it would get too confusing and in a way deviates from the spirit of the thread. No segue's will be permitted, single tracks only please. I will add that one of my picks would have been a segue, if we allowed them.

If you pick such and such song from such and such concert one pick, then you can pick the next segue'd song next pick as long as noone else has picked any version of either song by the same artist. That is fair. 1 pick, 1 song, but voters will still consider it as a segue. This applies to live versions only, studio medleys are out.

Only three spots left!
 
Last edited:
Kings Faithful

Kings Faithful

Starter
#54
#54
Well if you were gonna sign up for this draft you shouldve had some good knowledge of what to pick! haha....Heres a tip. Don't discredit songs just because you don't like them, or they are too "girlie". Many of the all time great singles are from women.
 
Bricklayer

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#55
#55
Kings Faithful said:
Well if you were gonna sign up for this draft you shouldve had some good knowledge of what to pick! haha....Heres a tip. Don't discredit songs just because you don't like them, or they are too "girlie". Many of the all time great singles are from women.
Click to expand...
If this one goes anything like the other music draft, I think you'll quickly find most everybody picking for their own personal preference rather than trying to collect critical accalimed darlings. Of course if the twain can be combined... :p
 
VF21

VF21

Super Moderator Emeritus
SME
#56
#56
Kings Faithful said:
Well if you were gonna sign up for this draft you shouldve had some good knowledge of what to pick! haha....Heres a tip. Don't discredit songs just because you don't like them, or they are too "girlie". Many of the all time great singles are from women.
Click to expand...
What are you talking about? Too girlie? EXCUSE ME?
 
Kings Faithful

Kings Faithful

Starter
#57
#57
Yeah im doing a combination of critically acclaimed and my favs because im into alot of different genres and i listen to it all really. Oh and when i mean to "girlie" im saying if you want to win dont be afraid to choose like a Britney Spears song for instance....(I.E. not my actual choice, avoid Britney Spears if possible).....Haha.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.