I should perhaps note at this point that continuing to refer to Kevin as "a 30pt scorer" is a bit silly -- yes, he scored 30pts...for 5 games! He is not, never has been, and never wil be, a 30pt a season scorer, and if he was this thread would not make much sense.
But to start the season we were clearly running a highly highly Kevincentric offense that saw him taking more than twice as many shots as any other King. And so yes, Kevin was scoring 30, but nobody else was scoring more than 11. And yes, part of that is of course because you can't have a Kevin Martin score 30 without it taking away from the other guys because he is just a scorer -- he can't create for others along the way. But now that guys are going to have 8 weeks operating under a different system, I see no possible way that everybody just returns to Kevin scores 30 while I wait for scraps mode. With Reke in particular there is just no way.
And that's actually the biggest argument for considering a trade -- not because Kevin is Kevin, Reke is a SG, or whatever, but because looking ahead in your mind's eye it is almost impossible to see Reke playing at his best (let's call Utah his best) and Kevin playing at his best (let's call the 30pts a game streak his best) happening at the same time. If we run the Kevin gets 30 offense, everybody, inclkuding Reke, is knocked back into passivity. If Reke is running wild, he's not going to stop and get the ball to Kevin in his spots -- to that degree at least the Reke as non-PG people are right. He creates for teammates, his drive and kick game is emerging, but its not as if he's coming down he floor looking to get the ball to so and so just right in so and so's favorite spot, or just wanting to hand the ball off and stand around while Kevin does his thing. Just not his game. Its would be madness to intentionally dump a star and choose to only have one star instead of two...unless you can look at playing styles and say the two stars aren't really complimentary and maybe you can bring back a better fit in trade.
And so Kevin comes back....he's not going to average 30. And the risk is maybe it doesn't work. Maybe he only averages 20 and he and Reke struggle to both be at the top of their games together. Oil and water. I suspect that we are going to have a chance to find out, because Geoff Petrie for a long long time now has been "patient" to the point of somnalence on these issues. One of the reasons the whole genius thing got so ridiculous -- he waited too long on nearly every piece he had, waiting and waitng and waiting to see how it worked long after it was obvious it would not work and watching his assets depreciate across the board before selling low. He waited too long with Peja, with Bibby, with Ron, with Brad. Always wanting to wait a little longer and "evaluate" and in the process the rest of the league got to "evaluate" too and didn't like what they saw. If Kevin and Reke do not work together, it could be the same thing again. Rather than selling high, you end up "evaluating" and trying to sell a 20ppg asset rather than a 30ppg asset. You have to be intuitive and ahead of the game rather than reactive and pedantically wait until its obvious to everyone else. What was Bill Walsh's thing? "Better to trade a guy a year too early than to trade him a year too late?"