Disregarding the "hoopla," there is nothing remotely "one in a million" about what happened with Jeremy Lin. From a basketball perspective, if Jeremy Lin is "one in a million," then so is Isaiah Thomas. So, for that matter, are Steve Blake, Monta Ellis, George Hill, Jodie Meeks, Patty Mills, Ramon Sessions, Goran Dragic and Danny Green. Which is to say, not really "one in a million" at all.
Isaiah Thomas can play. But just about everybody in the NBA can play; with the exception of the international selections, there isn't anyone in the NBA that wasn't dominant at the previous level. Most of these guys can put up numbers, if you just give them minutes and touches. Could any of them average twenty points, if you gave them fifteen shots? I stand by what I've said several times before, I think that there are a lot more than you think there are.
Isaiah Thomas is good, but he's not special. He's not doing anything that's never been done, or can't be duplicated in similar circumstances. But, you know what? Let's suppose, for the sake of argument, that Thomas is as special as you think he is; he's still a terrible fit in the starting lineup. And this false dilemma that we have to ride him because we don't have anyone better is a total canard. In terms of talent, we don't need somebody "better." We need someone who is a better fit. Is that someone Fredette? Probably not, but it's hard to say. He's been given opportunity, but not really: he hasn't been given significant non-garbage time minutes with the starters, like Thomas has. He hasn't been given the same opportunities to play through his mistakes. If Thomas makes two mistakes in a row, he's going to get a chance to make the third, and the fourth, and the fifth. If Fredette makes two mistakes in a row, he's probably not going to see the court for the rest of the game.
Am I stumping for Fredette? **** no; I like Jimmer Fredette even less than I like Isaiah Thomas. But I'll tell you what I don't think: I don't think that a player who can do what Fredette can do is incapable of starting. I look at it this way: even if Fredette never gets any better, he's Derek Fisher: you telling me that there's no room in the NBA for the Derek Fishers of the world to start? Do I think that he could start on this team? Well, I'm not one of those people who believes that we'd only average eighty points a game, if not for Isaiah Thomas, let's put it that way. Would I start him? No, but I wouldn't start Thomas, either. Given the option of the three point guards we have, and only those three, I'd start McCallum, and give Thomas thirty-to-thirty-five minutes off the bench; I certainly don't believe that we'd be any worse than 17-34.