There's something I don't understand about this. I haven't really thought about it before this thread and I'm not trying to be obtuse. It seems to me that when the Kings had to declare who they were making available Peeler was under contract and could have been made available. The expansion draft was in June and he signed with the Wizards a month later in July of 04.
The Kings must have known after the season ended that Peeler was going to opt out. I've been trying to research the issue out of curiosity and it does not appear that the Kings were surprised by his decision. So, isn't the issue as you pointed out that they protected Songaila?
No, Songaila is the second issue.
The main issue, the big mistake, was undoubtedly Peeler. Everybody knew the expansion draft was coming for YEARS before it did. We failed to plan for the event. All you have to do to protect yourself in one of those is make sure you have somebody under contract at the time of the draft who is expendable. Its not hard. Its so not hard in fact that no other team in the entire league gave up as juicy of a piece as Gerald. Young, cheap, full of potential. I mean, duh. Songaila only becomes an issue because of the Peeler mistake. If we plan ahead, we don't have to expose Darius either.
the rule is/was:
1) you can protect up to 8 players under contract for next year on your roster (i.e., not FAs, guys under contract for the following year), any players beyond 8 are exposed to the draft
2) if you have 8 or fewer players uncer contract for next year, you still always have to expose at least 1 (so every team exposes at least 1)
examples:
a) you have 10 players under contract for next season; you get to protect 8 of the 10, you must leave the other 2 available for the draft;
b) you have 8 players under contract for next season; normally you could protect 8 players, but since that would mean you were exposing nobody to the draft, you can only protect 7 players, and expose 1 to the draft
In any case, you are ALWAYS going to have to expose 1, and you know that before the season begins, and know that at the trade deadline, and yet we took no action to protect ourselves by securing an expendable piece that we knew would be available for exposure. Peeler's opt out was absolutely the deal breaker -- much talked about at the time. If he does not opt out, then we list him as the exposed player, and protect Webb, Peja, Miller, Bibby, Christie, BJax, Songaila, Wallace (8 players). Once he opts out and becomes a FA, he is not eligible for the draft and we still have to expose 1 of our 8 players (see example b, above). That is when we chose Songaila over Gerald.
P.S. I should note here that its possible we were not thinking Darius would turn out to be anything and figured we could always just expose him, in which case a) why sign him at all; and b) our great plan in that situation was still to intentionally expose another young player -- exactly the type of guy the expansion teams are looking for.