Good post. I agree with everything.
I don’t think Holmes is a horrible defender. He’s the best switching big man on the Kings, which isn’t saying much in itself. The problem is, if the Kings comtinue to play the same defense with the same personnel, Holmes lack of length will continue to be an issue for the Kings. It’ll be a layup line, because the guards are poor defenders and don’t have the length to help or deter their man once they’re driving. Holmes, having moved out of his spot on switches or if he’s helping, just doesn’t have the length to recover and bother driving opponents.
And even if the Kings played a defense where they funneled players to him, there would certainly be much better options to play that role. Like Whiteside or Capela or Noel or…
Ultimately, if the Kings retain Holmes and start him, they would need to trade Buddy, get a few jumbo wings, and hope Fox and Hali take a big step forward. That’s a lot of moving parts for a player, who is best suited as a scoring, bench big. He has value and I like him, but certainlu not more than $10m per yr.