Well, I agree with all that except I'm way more bullish on Ricky Rubio. Everybody in Spain, if not all of pro basketball Europe thinks he's at least as good as Calderon right now and certainly way better than other NBA Spaniard PG's Navarro or Rodriguez. I don't know if he'll be a big time NBA star, but I think he certainly has a chance - in the Steve Nash, John Stockton ball handling, set-up mold. No one would deny that Rubio is a quintessential natural/pure/true PG who at 18-19 has barely scratched the surface of what he can become. He may not be a big time NBA scorer but, he will I think go right on racking up assists like a pin ball machine. If an PG scoring machine is preferred then little pure shooter Stephon Curry is an available template - but I strongly prefer Rubio over him.
I will readily admit that I might just not be seeing this one right and may look positively stupid someday when someone re-quotes me this thread, but watching USA/Spain over the summer and again this week online, Rubio looks roughly as quick and athletic as Jason Kidd right now, as in the Jason Kidd who is 35 years old. Kidd isn't taking the Mavericks anywhere despite having all the passing and savvy in the world in large part because he's not quick enough to guard anyone anymore. Rubio's really crafty, he's good at changing speeds and fooling guys. But I worry that he's not really going to be quick enough to get around people, and he'd be a defensive liability. I know Rubio's supposed to be a good defender, but Spain played zone whenever Chris Paul came in, which tells you something, and I wasn't really impressed with his defense when he was guarding guys one on one.
I don't see him as a Calderon -- he's not as quick (not that Calederon is overwhelmingly quick, but he's quicker than Rubio), and Calderon can shoot really well, which is a big part of his game. Rubio can't shoot. His jumper is not only ugly and not very accurate, he takes forever to get it off and thus it's not at all a reliable weapon to open up his passing game. (Navarro played far better than Rubio in the Gold Medal game, btw)
I definitely agree with you that I would prefer a PG on the pure/passing spectrum, particularly if Kevin Martin is on the team, because Kevin really needs to be set up in order to be the most effecitve. And Teague isn't that kind of a point guard. But there just isn't an athletic passing point guard in this draft, other than Collison, who is looking worse and worse as the season goes on. So barring The Gambit, if I were Petrie I'd draft Teague and hope his ability to break down the defense and get out on the break compliments Kevin's game. Teague has the raw skills, and I'd hope he'd look to pass more in the NBA.
Here's the bias I'm bringing to the table: I'm sick, sick, sick of unathletic players on the Kings. Bibby drove me crazy, Peja drove me crazy, Brad drove me crazy, late model Shareef drove me crazy when he started breaking down. The Kings need athletes. The league is getting faster, stronger, and more athletic. I can't bear to watch anymore throwback guys.