You are arguing with the wrong person. If you read my earlier posts, I'm a Tyreke fan and hope he is retained.
I'm simply stating what I think is the FO's sentiment. The FO is very high on Mac. He would really have to struggle in summer league and training camp for them to not start him. The FO have hinted that they are looking for a SF upgrade in free agency. That really just leaves PG for Tyreke.
I just can't see us paying $11 mil for a 6th man. We already have a $8 million a yr 6th man in Thornton (he is not traded at this point). The FO will only pay starter money for a starter. It is what it is.
I'm not arguing with the fact that
you want to retain Evans. I'm arguing that you think our FO would only sign Evans if they think he is a PG. Let's say they think he is a SG and they let him walk. What you have just done is lost a potential star player for nothing. Your only other star player on the team is Cousins. With our youngsters and Cousins developing, it is unlikely we will be drafting early enough in the lottery to net us another star like talent. Sacramento has never been known to attract star level talent in free agency, so where are we going to get our second star to put next to Cousins? It could be McLemore. He does have potential to be a 2nd/3rd option star in this league, but that's a long way out. We can try trading our scraps (Thomas, Fredette, Thornton, Thompson, & Patterson) for one, but how often do teams give up star player talents for players like those?
The point I'm making is if our FO is smart, which I assume they are, they will match any offer for Evans. Let's assume he gets offered the max and the Kings match.
If they see Evans as being worth the max and they match it
They should start Evans at SG and ease McLemore into the NBA. Again, this kid is only 20 years old. He's most likely going to need time to adjust. If McLemore doesn't show well in his time off the bench, continue to start Evans at SG and keep babying McLemore so we don't jeopardize his development. If McLemore shows well off the bench, bring him into the starting lineup and push Evans to PG. If they work together, we have our backcourt of the future. If they don't work together or Evans is not capable of being a PG, you trade either Evans or McLemore. Evans is a star level talent and should be able to net you an equal talent in return. If McLemore is showing well like he is in this scenario, I'm sure his value will be very high as well. It might not be as valuable as Evans, but he should be able to net you an equal value player as well. The debate on which one we should trade if McLemore shows well and Evans doesn't workout at PG is an entirely separate conversation.
If they don't see Evans as being worth the max and they match it
In this case, you can look to trade him immediately and net an equal talent back. If there were teams that offered him the max, then I'm sure you'll find trading partners who won't see his max contract as a negative.
Either way you are going to have talent on your team. If you let him walk for nothing, you're making a big mistake.