I appreciate your concerns, and they're justified. (That would be a great name for a TV series) What Bennett has going for him along with his athleticism, is that he's very very skilled, and skilled players are seldom busts. Athletic players without skills have the higest percentage of being busts. As for his defense. I saw him play very good defense at times, and not much other times. That tells me he's capable, but at times gets down on himself and pouts, which leads to lack of effort at the other end of the court. I'll tell you this! Michael Carter-Williams scares me far more than Bennett does. But, if for some reason we draft him, I'll be his biggest fan and hope I've been wrong about him.
Mate, I value you opinion highly on these draft kids coming through and I have one question that keeps bugging me with Bennett. Can he genuinely play as a full time SF in the NBA?
That is one question that I think a lot of teams are asking. He won't be able to be a genuine, full time PF in the NBA because the length will trouble him. I am sure offensively, he could play a fair bit at SF as he can use his size to post up smaller players and his long range shooting is a genuine threat BUT can he guard athletic SFs in the NBA?
I know no one can stop LeBron but some players can make him earn it. Can Bennett (in time) be the player that could guard the likes of LeBron, Carmelo, Pierce (he is close to retiring), Gallinari, etc? That is one key question I have here.
One thing that Bennett has going for him that the likes of T-Rob, Williams etc did not have going for them is his skill level and face up game. That will translate but in the NBA, you can only play position that you can guard and at 6'8" or there about, he will not be able to guard the games best PFs on a regular basis and the question then becomes, is he a SF at the next level or is he a tweener that is without position!
There have been plenty of tweeners that have gone on to have a productive NBA careers (eg Jamison) but none of them have gone on to be the sort of players that you always want on your team because they have a defined position. There is no doubt the kid has the skills but can he play as a full time SF in the NBA? If he can, with that size and length and the skill level, he could be one of the better SFs in the league. If he can't, he will struggle to be a good player in the league.