I previously questioned Doncic's star potential as well. Saw him as a guy who capped out at 17-5-5, which is good, but not star status. I thought Ben Simmons was a guy who would cap out at 5apg (he averaged 4.8apg at LSU). I just didn't see him as a natural facilitator. In his first year in the NBA, he's averaged 8.2apg. I was being extremely unfair in thinking his potential could only go so high. I recognized I was doing the same to Doncic.
His athleticism does limit his ceiling compared to the other guys, but he's just so good in the other areas that I think he can make it up. He's a 6'8 228lb point-guard. That's an entirely different territory. That's Lebron and Magic. He's not just a point-forward like Khris Middleton or Gordon Hayward. He's a legitimate PG imo. That's what makes him special.
I agree with your analysis and I also don't see a problem with Doncic as a defender.
His defensive awareness is very good with head on a swivel off the ball. No problems there.
I was surprised to see he made only on 31% on 3s.
I love his shot mechanics and think he can be a 45% three pointer shooter in the NBA but this Euro number was low.
He may need to speed up his shot release or just get in more reps and larger sample size, I am not sure.
But I think the Kings are taking Bagley #2. I think the Suns are taking Ayton at #1.
I reserve the right to change my mind and might, but I think this is the best course of action for both teams.
I anticipate the Suns and Kings will pass on Doncic not because they don't like/love him as a player but because they like these guys that much more.
I read these critics Bagley can't shoot....give me a break.
Guy has a beautiful stroke and the makings of a devastating face-up game.
I wish he used his right hand more but he can develop it.
He has a sweet half hook and he's super quick off first and second bounce a la Anthony Davis.
One of the best questions you can ask when scouting these guys is "how easy does he make the game look"?
Bagley makes the game look easy.