To some degree, I can understand where some of you are coming from. To many of you, defense means blocking shot after shot. Protecting the rim is the what turns people on. Willie is a different kind of player. If anyone had to listen to the Clipper broadcast as I was forced to do because the Clips and the Lakers are blacked out on NBA TV in my area, then you would have heard Don McLean in the 2nd half raving about Willie, and what a rare defender he is. He said that Willie is the best ball stoppiing big man in the entire NBA.
The regular announcer mentioned that Willic doesn't block shots like Jordan. McLean said that blocking shots is overrated and that Jordan can't do what Willie does. He said that Willie is a gap filler. He leaves his man and stops the ball where ever there's a break down in the defense, and then gets back to his man before the ball can be passed to him. Sometimes two or three times in the same sequence. He predicted that Willie would eventually be one of the best defensive big men in the NBA. He did mention that Willie does on occasion make a mistake on switchs and the Kings end up with two players guarding the same man. But thats about it.
When Willie started his career at Kentucky, Calapari had him positioned in the post, and he blocked a lot of shots. But in his second year, he started having him switch out on SF's and SG's because Willie could stay in front of them, and his size negated their ability to get of a shot. As a result, he didn't block as many shots, and his rebounding numbers went down. Willie was the main pick and roll defender, and was probably the best pick and roll defender in college.
If you want to pass judgement on Willie's defense, then you have the watch only him on defense and see what he does. Willie is the team band-aid. He plugs holes where ever they appear. Sometimes that leaves him out of position. If you only see the out of position part. or the failure of a teammate to switch when Willie leaves his man, you'll think it's Willies fault. Most of the time, it's not! Keep track of how many times you see an opposition player wide open at the three point line. Keep track of who is doing the run out at him. About 50% of the time, it's Willie, but it's not Willie's man. In the last game, Griffin only scored once on Willie in the post, and he didn't score once with Willie guarding him away from the basket. Unfortunately Skal couldn't say the same thing.