Added another classic to my watched list, following up on a
@Capt. Factorial recommendation from years ago.
Limelight (1952)
This is how dedicated I was to finally make good on a promise to the Cap to see this movie. Although this is filmed in English, the Kanopy version I watched was dubbed into German, and I couldn’t figure out how to switch it. So I watched an English film, dubbed into German, with English subtitles.
Obviously, dampens my ability to evaluate the performances. But I got the gist. And all the songs were in English.
The story is eerily semi-autobiographical as Charlie Chaplin plays a famous comedian past his prime and derided by the public as old fashioned and out-of-touch. Unlike Chaplin (but reportedly inline with his father) the comedian turns to alcohol. While on a bender, he stops the suicide of a struggling young ballerina, and becomes something of a mentor to her.
The film is touching, sentimental, nostalgic, tragic but overall, to put simply, kind, especially against the backdrop of real world censorship and repudiation of Chaplin for McCarthy Era accusations of being a communist. Chaplin’s character has a very earnest and selfless drive to see his protege succeed and thrive. Imagine
A Star is Born with an ending that I wouldn’t be surprised to learn inspired Aronofsky’s
The Wrestler / Black Swan.
Unfortunately the film didn’t fully land with me. Perhaps it was the German dubbing, but I found the ballerina to be overly theatrical and “hysterical” to the point of being annoying, and her devotion to Chaplin borders on uncomfortably obsessive. Meanwhile Chaplin’s character is supposed to be outdated, and there are a few flashbacks to his old-fashioned vaudevillian performances that simply don’t land with the audience anymore. But when he gets his groove back and plays a three act set that brings the house down for one last swan song performance … I can’t really tell a difference of what’s changed or why the audience suddenly loves him again.
Regardless, Chaplin toward the end of his career may not have been able to make an especially impactful film like
City Lights, Modern Times, or
The Great Dictator, but he certainly could make a sweet and interestingly melancholy one.
Shame blind hatred and political agendas got in the way of something so kind.