To me, LaMelo has that "I'm going to put the team on my back and take over" mentality. The same kind that Luka had coming into the league...although he's not nearly as good as Luka. At least not yet. He has that bulldog mentality.
Tyrese looks to fit into the team better and do what he can do within the flow of the game while rarely ever trying to take over. In fact it seems as if he purposely tries not to take over most of the time. He's extremely good at doing what he does because he almost always makes the team better when he's on the floor.
I will always take the player with the LaMelo mentality as long as they show the skills to back it up because those are the guys that have a higher chance to turn into the players like Lebron, Giannis, Harden, Luka etc. Tyrese's future is more difficult to gauge because there aren't many players like him right out of college. There are many different ways he could go. He could be a Joe Ingles or a Doug Christie or a Gordon Hayward or maybe even something better? I don't really know and it's not a knock on him at all because he's already proven he's going to be an above average player in some capacity. It's just to me, LaMelo has more of a possibility to knock it out of the park than Tyrese does and that's why I think he has the higher ceiling.
Not saying that he will ever be half the player, but Magic Johnson was very much the same way early in his career. And even sporadically through his career. He learned what he needed to do and when he needed to do it.
If the game dictated for Magic to score 42, he’d focus on doing that. But he was much more happy and content to get everyone else involved as a first option.
Thus far, I see Tyrese the same way. He prefers to play ‘team’ ball and make the right basketball decisions. He doesn’t want to force things and be selfish. And that’s honestly the the right way to play.
Think of it is playing from inside out. For many decades prior to this ridiculous 3 point hero ball era, teams played inside to setup the outside shot. In the NFL they established the run to setup the pass.
In basketball you should play unselfishly and make the smart plays until such time that you are forced to become selfish. That’s what I believe Tyrese will learn eventually.
I’m actually leery of any 19 year old that comes in with a selfish “put the team on my back” mentality. I don’t believe it translates to future success as much as the unassuming, unselfish type.
Not so surprising to me, the player widely believed to have been the best player the past decade, LBJ, is a player in the Magic mold. A player that prefers to get others involved and make the smart basketball play. Like Magic, he had to learn when to become selfish. But he mostly still defers and makes the best play.
And also not surprisingly to me, the Warriors dominated for years also playing a less selfish brand of ball. While guys like Steph and Klay have taken turns carrying the team, they still prefer to make the right plays as the top option.
Meanwhile all the ball dominant chuckers around the league mostly languish w/o titles. Even KD had to join the Warriors to get one. And now the bearded hag is trying to do the same with KD, as the hero ball BS has produced Jack squat.
Kobe is the only “me” player that has seen major success. But even 3 of the titles he was part of were largely made possible because he had to the benefit of playing alongside one of the most physically dominant big men of all time. And if not for Kobe’s selfishness and need to be the “man” and put the team on his own back, he very well might have 6 or 7 titles to his resume instead of 5.
To conclude, give me the unselfish player 99/100 times.