But how much of either of those is his fault? His defense just utterly collapsed in on itself on both occasions.
A lot of it his fault. Specifically the 28-3 collapse.
His play calling was largely responsible for the comeback. That, and Matt Ryan not making experienced QB decisions.
But I’d argue the 7-step drop pass plays he called in the 4th Q were the biggest bonehead decisions of the game. The first one resulted in the strip sack that started the comeback, then the 2nd was after the Julio Jones catch that should have sealed the game. The only thing the Falcons couldn’t afford was a sack.
But instead of a run or a quick pass and throw it away of it’s not there, Shanahan dials up the only type of pass play that could allow a big loss. You could argue that Matt Ryan has to know to throw the ball away, and I’d agree, but I also believe the OC has to take that out of the equation by calling a higher percentage play. The Falcons didn’t need to get a first down. So no need for the long drop back. Bubble screen, run play, quick out, anything like that would have been ok.
It was just like the Seahawks boneheaded slant call at the 1. Unlike many, I had no issue with them going away from their tendency, but a slant over the middle with all defenders near the LOS has a high likelihood of exactly what happened. Rolling Wilson out for a pass run option was the smart play, but they didn’t do it. But I digress.
Shanahan most certainly was a big part of that collapse with his situational play calling.