C'mon Brick. Please tell me you're not becoming one of these SL guys? What this kid did or didn't do in SL means next to nothing. WCS didn't play well, by most accounts, and yet we know he can play in the NBA. Most importantly, this kid just turned 19 less than 2 weeks ago. I remember Dirk Nowitzki and Steve Nash not being very impressive early on either -- despite being more accomplished -- and we know how they turned out. Obviously nobody expects this kid to reach those levels, but they are 2 good examples of how you really can't know much of anything this early. If he still stinks 2-3 years from now, I'll be concerned. Right now, it should be expected.
You honestly think there's a chance the team's top draft pick won't be on the roster? I certainly don't. Hell, they kept Eric Moreland and Duje Dukan on the roster last season and they almost never played.
Active roster.
And I have ALWAYS been a SL guy. You can tell tons, and its always been a big leg up for me with new guys since I only sporadically watch college ball. you just have to know what to watch.
Here's Papa right now:
Good
-- potentially good hands and soft touch as a finisher. I say potentially because he's shown it before, but barely did in SL.
-- can set a big screen
Bad
-- ineffective rebounder relying purely on size, slow to react, not physical, not aggressive
-- ineffective rim protector despite size, lacks lift, explosiveness, when he challenges guys shoot over him. think Aaron Gray.
-- ineffective defender away from the hoop, per usual for a guy his size -- they have to dominate near the rim to make up for it
-- no post game, just barely in its infancy
-- no real evidence of a jumper, but fact he takes them means he might at least have some base to work from
-- I'm not worried about the out of shape part. That's one of those things you have to know to ignore in SL.
In short, he did not show he was an NBA player. If he was 6'10" and an undrafted free agent we would have already forgotten his name.
Obviously he will be on the 15 man roster, but that's a problem now. He is a project. He wanted to come over which was nice to see, but how is he going to feel to be trading in minutes for one of the power teams in Europe in front of dangerously rabid fans for a couple of thousand diehards in Reno and long bus rides? Dunno. Do know if we keep him on the active roster he will be taking a spot from somebody more able to help us today. If Papa had shown no skills but was active, physical, and aggressive he would have ways to contribute. But instead he showed the physical game of a skilled player without the skills.
P.S. After seeing Vlade's post summer league interview it seems clear that Papa may be a bit of a personal pet project. That's both good and bad. bad because you don't want your GM projecting himself onto kids as a reason to draft them, good because obviously the kid could use some help and having the GM as a part time adviser/coach can only help.