bajaden
Hall of Famer
I think the switching argument is overblown and overplayed. Whether you're 5'9" or 6"2 inches, you're not going to be able to guard power forwards or 3s in switching situations. It's up to the team defense to counter that situation. The argument is similar to saying that more teams are going to be trying to put a power forward in isolation situations on defense with their point guard, so we should ding the power forward heavily for not doing well in those situations. If that's truly the worst that will happen with IT, then I will gladly live with it. It's much better than geting reamed by opposing point guards who get to the basket at will with no pressure. Would IT be great coming of the bench? Sure. He's good starting, so I think he'd be excellent off the bench. But right now there's not anyone that close on this team in passing skill, especially in pick and roll situations, and with the big men on this team like Couisns, and now Robinson, that is very important, imo. IT is the best guard this team has in pressuring the ball on defense, passing the ball, overall shooting, 3 pt shooting, running a pick and roll, running a fast break, and breaking a pressure defense bring the ball up the court. Unless we trade for a top 10 guard, I don't see the purpose in not starting him.
I don't disagree with you. I certainly wasn't being critical of IT. I said his only liability was his height. And regardless of what people might think, it is a liability, but not so huge as to have sleepless nights over it. For IT to guard a Westbrook or a Wall, or a Deron Williams, he has to play up on them. If he gives them space, they can use that space to shoot over him. So the only way to be real effective is to body up on them. Where that can present a problem is that gives the very quick PG's like the one's mentioned, the ability to put the ball on the floor and get by you. Like I said, I'm not going to lose any sleep over it, but if height didn't matter at all, we could have guys 5'5" out there playing PG. Its better to be tall and quick than short and quick. But if your short, you damm well better be quick.