Best Talent Evaluator

#1
With all the recent trades, we all have form some new opinion of Geof Petrie. We all thought he was flawless when it comes to trading and moving pieces, but I think one main aspect that he was average and not so "godly" is at scouting. Since 1999 with the Jason Williams pick, we never really manage to pick up any from the draft that is exceptional. Granted, they are all good picks, but all journeyman at best. Jason Williams had the most potential to be a star, but he's turning into a career starter. Hedo, with all of his potential, is still a 6th man. Gerald Wallace, while it's still early for him, has not done anything worthy of extreme merit this year. This year, we drafted Kevin Martin. I can only hope that he will defy the trend.

When it comes to scouting and recruiting through draft, I have to say the Spur and the Bulls are the best at it. Spur got lucky with drafting Duncan, no doubt about that. But they were incredible in picking Tony Parker at 28th and Manu Ginobili as the 32nd pick in the second round is damn good.

Then there's the Bull, sure they made some dumb choice in trading, but i have to say they're the best talent evaluator out there in drafting. I dont think any of their draft choice is bust so far. Even Curry and Chandler have a pretty bright future ahead. Had they not trade away Elton Brand for Chandler, This could have been their lineup: Brad Miller, Elton Brand, Ron Artest, Jamal Crawford, and Kirk Hinrich with Curry off the bench. That is a championship caliber team. I would include Ben Gordon and Luol Deng as the bench, but i figure they would have won too much the year before to pick up those guys.

I think for our success, we really need to scout better. Look for that diamond in the rough type.
 

Bricklayer

Don't Make Me Use The Bat
#2
Geoff's been very sold with his drafts, but nothing more. He gets players at the positions he drafts that are about as good as their draft position. A starter (not spectacular one) with the #7 pick, a 6th man with the #15 pick etc. He drafts right about on schedule. But its true that in all of his years for us the only guy who really turned out to be a bit of a steal was Peja, and that may well have been because Geoff was just ahead of the curve in looking overseas.


Where he's excelled is in his pinpoint trading -- the ability to spot a player in the legaue that would fit our system and nab him.
 
A

AriesMar27

Guest
#3
well.... if we were only winning 28 games like the bulls were, we could have gotten hinrich... who i love to death, too bad the clippers didnt get him..... outside of parker and ginobili, what othe rteams have done that great at drafting with winning teams? the laker? ooh sasha.... the mavs? i mean the clippers have gotten some amazing draft picks but sterling is a cheap bastard and has lost some great players.... the way that the nba is today the clippers would be a sick as team if they had kept their players and gone after someone like nash last summer.... if they still had q, odom and miles with a real point guard right now.... damn. that would be the tam to beat with miles, q, simmons, jaric and livingston coming off of the bench... odom could play some pf if need be.... hell, even with brunson, that team would kick azz....

go clippers.... to bad they dont have those guys anymore.....
 
#4
Pacboy said:
When it comes to scouting and recruiting through draft, I have to say the Spur and the Bulls are the best at it. Spur got lucky with drafting Duncan, no doubt about that. But they were incredible in picking Tony Parker at 28th and Manu Ginobili as the 32nd pick in the second round is damn good.
Ginobili was the 57th pick.

Best scouting? I'm going with SA and Phx as the top two. I'll also give Chicago props. They've made some good picks since 99, scored a few times by taking guys (whose stocked slipped) out of big schools like UConn, Kansas, and Duke.

Here's who Phx has drafted since 1995. Their highest pick from this list was #7 (Deng).

Luol Deng
Zarko Cabarkapa
Amare Stoudemire
Casey Jacobsen
Alton Ford
Jake Tsakalidis
Shawn Marion
Stephen Jackson
Steve Nash
Russ Millard
Ben Davis
Michael Finley
Mario Bennett
Chris Carr