Anyone interested in a video game draft?

How can a video game go out of its prime? Dust in the cartridge, scratch on the disc?

If you mean best versions available...well that's totally opinion.

Good point, the only thing I can think of really is graphics. Obviously todays games have way better graphics than say games released for the NES.

Anyway, I'm thinking about having it wide open, as that seems the most popular way to go. I'll start thinking of some official rules and post them whenever I can. Meanwhile, I'll make a list of participants, so let me know if you're interested by posting here or PMing me. How many people should participate? 16 would be too many I would think, how about 10 or 12??
 
I don't think 16 would really be too many. I disagree with a poster earlier, I think there would easily be enough great games for a 16x20 draft, if the drafters were well-versed enough. I mean, that's only 320 games. That about how many come out a year, if not less.

Problem is there might not be enough interest for 16. You might want to open the draft with a possibility of 16, but if we get like a week in and only 13 or 14 people are signed up, either limit it at that amount, or let people know from the beginning that anyone past 10 or 12+ is at risk of being cut.

tl;dr I'm in
 
How can a video game go out of its prime?

In 1990 I would have sold a kidney for Super Mario Brothers III.
Now it's somewhere in a cardboard box in my parent's garage.

I'd say it's no longer in its prime.

The prime clause is a way of leveling the playing field so the draft doesn't consist of an overload of modern day phenomenons.

As in the pound-for-pound arguement in boxing, something like a "level of enjoyment at its peak" or a byte-for-byte position.
 
I think for in the prime means that the game is considered re: at the time it was released.

And I guess I would be in, but I'll see when you do signups.
 
See I was thinking about doing something like this for the next TDOS, but if its gonna happen this year then I guess I'm in.
 
Ok, some posters haven't indicated if they're interested or not, so so far the participants are:

SacKings7
NoBonus
AleksandarN
tradepeja
WarHawk
venom_7
Löwenherz
bdouble013
Spike
kings4lyfe32
SLAB
kingsfan916
dukeswh
Bricklayer
Gary
Jespher
 
Last edited:
Tropical Island Video Game Draft

Most of you should know the situation by now, but I'll go over it again. You are stranded on a tropical island by yourself. You have an unlimited supply of water and food, and everything else needed to survive. You also happen to have a solar powered PC and TV, with every console ever made, as well as a few solar powered arcade games. Obviously there is no cable or satellite available, and no internet connection. You are allowed to bring 20 games with you.

Design: The official draft order will be decided by a randomizer. As in the other drafts, each participant will select a game when it is their turn, stating the name, platform, and year of release, as well as an official picture for the game (game box, screenshot, etc). Any additional pictures will be in a second post using spoiler tags. Along with a picture, a brief explanation of why you chose the game will also be required.

Once the draft process is finished, a board-wide voting will take place on the participants collections to see who has the best collection.

As in the other draft threads, seeing as how it was my idea, I declare myself commissioner and will handle any rule changes, draft order, etc. A moderator may lend a hand if for some reason I am unavailable for an extended period of time.

Rules:

-20 Rounds (Serpentine)
- PC games, Arcade games, and Console games (Playstation, Xbox, Nintendo, Sega, etc.) are to be selected. Handheld console games may also be selected (PSP, Gameboy, Nintendo DS, etc.)
-Once your pick is made, you must PM the next person to speed things up.
-You have 24 hours after the last pick made to make your pick, at the end of which the next person may then make his or her pick. If you do not pick within 24 hours, the draft keeps going and you can post your game whenever you can. If you know you will be unavailable for an extended time, you can PM your pick(s) to another member to post your picks for you.

- When picking a game, state the name, platform, and year of release, as well as an official picture and a brief description of why you chose that particular game. (As in the rest of the drafts)
- Multiplayer and/or online features of any game will not be considered, as you are stranded on an island by yourself with no internet connection.
- As with the movie and music drafts, you cannot pick a game that hasn't been released in your country yet.
-You may not pick a game that has already been picked by another participant, even if the game is on multiple platforms
-Like the Babe Draft, games selected will be based on IN THEIR PRIME, as in, when they were first released.
- Games released only in Japan will not be considered.
- This draft will NOT be starting until one of the other drafts is finished, so be sure to sign up sometime before then. A maximum of 16 participants are allowed to sign up. First come, first serve.

If anybody has any other rule ideas or if I forgot something, let me know and I will consider making the necessary changes. Also thanks to Mr. Slim Citrus, tradepeja, and Bricklayer, as I have based my rules off of theirs in the other draft threads.

 
Last edited:

- You may not pick a game that has already been picked by another participant (doing so will void your pick) UNLESS it is for another platform. Each participant can pick a duplicate game (on a different platform) on only THREE separate occasions. (Example: NBA Live 2003, 2004, 2005 are taken for PS2. I may take all 3, and only 3, on a different platform (PC, Xbox).

Sign me up for sure, although I'd like a bit more clarity on this rule.

Also the no Japan games only rule is interesting. I don't like it very much, but I think its a fine rule when I think about it.

I almost thought for a second you had outlawed handheld games and i was gonna be pisssssssssssssed. Good thing I had just read it wrong.

Also, maybe the theme of the "island" should be different? Maybe we are stranded on a space-station for the rest of our lives or something more futuristic and video-gamey? I dunno, its trivial, just throwing things out there.
 
Sure, why not. Count me in.
Also, I think it may be best to allow a single pick/year for sports games per console instead of three, or else it may get really confusing. That, and it would allow for more creativity in the draft. I don't know how exciting it would be for everyone to have NBA Live (using your example), even though we all have different years/consoles.
 
Sign me up for sure, although I'd like a bit more clarity on this rule.

Also the no Japan games only rule is interesting. I don't like it very much, but I think its a fine rule when I think about it.

I almost thought for a second you had outlawed handheld games and i was gonna be pisssssssssssssed. Good thing I had just read it wrong.

Also, maybe the theme of the "island" should be different? Maybe we are stranded on a space-station for the rest of our lives or something more futuristic and video-gamey? I dunno, its trivial, just throwing things out there.

Ok you pick NBA Live 2006, for example, for PC. I may also pick NBA Live 2006, but NOT for PC. And this doesn't just apply to sports games, but for any game released on more than 1 platform. Spike brought up an interesting point about only allowing each person to do this once. This was my original idea, and I think I may go this way after all. It would allow for more diversity, so I'm gonna change that rule. Clearer?

Also I'm sticking to the no "Japan only" games. And yeah, handheld games are allowed. I was also thinking of adding a rule that says that we each have to pick at least 1 arcade, 1 pc, 1 console, and 1 handheld game, but I didn't add it because I figured most of us would do that anyway
 
Ok you pick NBA Live 2006, for example, for PC. I may also pick NBA Live 2006, but NOT for PC. And this doesn't just apply to sports games, but for any game released on more than 1 platform. Spike brought up an interesting point about only allowing each person to do this once. This was my original idea, and I think I may go this way after all. It would allow for more diversity, so I'm gonna change that rule. Clearer?

Also I'm sticking to the no "Japan only" games. And yeah, handheld games are allowed. I was also thinking of adding a rule that says that we each have to pick at least 1 arcade, 1 pc, 1 console, and 1 handheld game, but I didn't add it because I figured most of us would do that anyway


Um, okay, no. If someone picks a multi-platform game, they have selected the game. Someone else should not be able to take it even if it was available on separate platforms.

That'd be like allowing someone to take the VHS version of a movie and then allow the next person to take the DVD extended version of the same movie. Doesn't make any sense. Once you draft something, its gone.
 
Um, okay, no. If someone picks a multi-platform game, they have selected the game. Someone else should not be able to take it even if it was available on separate platforms.

That'd be like allowing someone to take the VHS version of a movie and then allow the next person to take the DVD extended version of the same movie. Doesn't make any sense. Once you draft something, its gone.

When you put it that way, that makes a lot of sense. I'm gonna have to think that one over. Luckily we've got some time before this thing gets going anyway
 
What do you mean?

He is referring to what you and me just talked about. I'm guessing he'd be against it just like I am. I am glad you are starting to see the problems with it though. It would really water down the idea of a "draft" with that rule in place.
 
He is referring to what you and me just talked about. I'm guessing he'd be against it just like I am. I am glad you are starting to see the problems with it though. It would really water down the idea of a "draft" with that rule in place.

Oh ok. Yeah you made a very good point. I'm gonna change that rule, and add Spike's rule of 1 sports series per console (Only one NBA Live title is allowed to be taken for PC, for example) because I highly doubt people are gonna be taking a lot of sports games (especially more than 1 of the same sport). I underestimated how many games are actually out there I guess. I'll make the necessary changes.
 
Last edited:
I actually think the years in the series should all be fair game, but the consoles should not be distinguished. Just for example - NHL 94 is a completely different beast than NHL 08 and yet there are reasons to choose each, or maybe even both if you are a die hard. But there really isn't much difference between NHL 08 on Xbox 360 vs PS3 especially when you strip out the multiplayer.

But I think I am going to sit this out. All the rules take a lot of fun out of my favorite games, not to mention the small handful of japanese games I would have to drop. I would be interested in gaming with other Kings Fans members and possibly doing some kind of gaming tournament down the road though.
 
Im in.

And off the top of my head I already have it narrowed down to two SNES games that I have LOVED through the years.

...Now which one will I take?
 
When you have the requisite number of people, let the moderators know and we'll split out the rules and make room for the ongoing list as with the other "desert island" threads.

:)
 
OK, I'm in, but I think a good chunk of my games I will choose have already been posted for a while.... :o
**NEW RULE** -As there are several new sports games every year for several platforms, only 1 specific game from each sports game series shall be taken per console. EXAMPLE: I may pick NBA Live 2005 for PS2. From then on, nobody else is allowed to pick an NBA Live title from any year for the PS2. Obviously, however, you may pick NBA 2K5 for the PS2, OR, another version of NBA Live for a different console.

So can I get clarification on this - why cannot someone pick a different NBA Live for the PS2 if they want to? It would be a different game than the one chosen, right? If they can choose another NBA Live for another platform, why not the PS2? Or has this been properly addressed and resolved above, I am too tired to figure it all out right now.
 
OK, I'm in, but I think a good chunk of my games I will choose have already been posted for a while.... :o


So can I get clarification on this - why cannot someone pick a different NBA Live for the PS2 if they want to? It would be a different game than the one chosen, right? If they can choose another NBA Live for another platform, why not the PS2? Or has this been properly addressed and resolved above, I am too tired to figure it all out right now.

No, thats his new rule that is almost as bad as his old one.

I am glad you are being flexible, really, but just drop these weird rules. If someone picks NBA Live 98, that game is off the board for all consoles it came out on, but any other NBA Live game is still draftable. This won't even be that big of a deal as I see very few sports games even going (especially recent ones) so I think we don't need all these unnecessary rules.

It is ridiculous to bar people from their favorite sports series on their favorite console just because some schmuck before them picked a completely different game in the series. Here's another example: If I pick Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band on vinyl record, why should no one else be able to pick any vinyl Beatles record? It isn't a perfect example, but I'm just trying to show you where the rule fails again.
 
I went back and edited a couple posts quoting my probable entire list of games I would choose. :o Thanks for understanding, as I really didn't think there would be enough gamers here to have one of these when I did that.

Mea culpa.
 
Ok, forgive me for being flexible, but I think I misunderstood what people have been saying, so I once again am going back to what I originally had thought. This draft seems to be a bit more tedious than the others. Sorry for all the confusion, I came up with these rules fairly quickly without thinking them through apparently
 
Last edited:
Ok, forgive me for being flexible, but I think I misunderstood what people have been saying, so I once again am going back to what I originally had thought. This draft seems to be a bit more tedious than the others

I don't think it's inherently tedious, it's just getting needlessly confused with all the questions, revisions, and footnotes. Just based on reading all the posts, I think almost everyone is actually on the same page regarding the details -- a game released on multiple consoles is the same game in each format, however, a new version of a game (often with changes to graphics and gameplay) is a different game.

The only place it gets even remotely complicated, as far as I can see, is in the case of expansion packs, as they don't technically even work unless you've got the original game already installed. With MMOs against the rules, however, I don't see it being as huge an issue as it could be.
 
Back
Top