Eason shoots 31.2% from 3 and 74.1% from the line. He can’t shoot the 3. The Monk Sabonis pick and roll is going to see Eason’s defender standing in the lane.
compare it to Smith who shoots this year 35.4% from 3 and 85.7% from the line. Not to mention Smith is close to Eason on Defense. The player we want is Smith not Eason. The near perfect complement to Sabonis is Smith not Eason.
So your only data point that has you picking Smith over Eason is a 25 game shooting sample size from Eason? Let's expand this and look at their careers...
Career 3P%
Eason = 33.8% (3.8 3PA per 36 min)
Smith = 33.8% (5.7 3PA per 36 min)
Career C&S 3P%
Eason =35.2% (3.6 3PA per 36 min)
Smith = 34.5% (4.7 3PA per 36 min)
Now I'm not saying Eason is a better shooter than Smith, but you're acting like Eason is a non-shooter by saying that "The Monk Sabonis pick and roll is going to see Eason’s defender standing in the lane" which is simply untrue. If we're finding success with the Monk & Sabonis pick & roll with shooters like Fox & DeRozan on the floor, I don't see why having a guy like Eason on the floor all of a sudden craters the effectiveness of that playtype.
As for your point that "Smith is close to Eason on defense," I completely disagree. Watch these guys play. It's a pretty drastic difference, but until then, here is how their advanced impact stats shake out (including their defense)...
OVERALL
VPM: Eason =
54th / Smith =
226th
EPM: Eason =
88th / Smith =
258th
LEBRON: Eason =
33rd / Smith =
211th
DARKO: Eason =
111th / Smith =
222nd
RAPM (2Y): Eason =
66th / Smith =
643rd
OFFENSE
O-VPM: Eason =
146th / Smith =
198th
O-EPM: Eason =
218th / Smith =
246th
O-LEBRON: Eason =
125th / Smith =
367th
O-DARKO: Eason =
216th / Smith =
208th
O-RAPM (2Y): Eason =
220th / Smith =
607th
DEFENSE
D-VPM: Eason =
21st / Smith =
260th
D-EPM: Eason =
21st / Smith =
264th
D-LEBRON: Eason =
14th / Smith =
88th
D-DARKO: Eason =
60th / Smith =
235th
D-RAPM (2Y): Eason =
29th / Smith =
620nd
And if I average those ranks across the 5 metrics, it comes out too…
Overall: Eason =
70th / Smith =
312th
Offense: Eason =
185th / Smith =
325th
Defense: Eason =
29th / Smith =
293rd
He's flat out wayyyy better than him defensively. In fact, he’s one of the most impactful defenders in the league. He is even more impactful than Smith offensively (despite Smith being a better shooter).
It would be criminal to consciously choose Smith over Eason.